Handicraft versus Chivalry: Town Community and Historical Progress in the Later Novels of Walter Scott
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17072/2073-6681-2022-2-111-119Keywords:
historical novel; historical narrative; medieval Scotland; medieval France; medieval culture; medieval town community; historical progress.Abstract
The article is devoted to two novels by Walter Scott in which the writer demonstrates his vision of the late Middle Ages having taken France and Scotland as bright examples. In these works, Scott, both at the level of the general concept, which reflects his understanding of historical progress, and at the level of the images of the novels and their narratives, reconstructs socio-political and moral-psychological role of the standoff between chivalry and town communities in the dynamic of the time. The novels convincingly show the peculiarity of the late stage of Scott’s creative work, when the narrative importance of the love-adventure knot in the plot increases, as does the role of real historical figures. In the after 1819 Scott’s novel, more obvious is the writer’s desire to embody his understanding of historical laws, based on a mixture of conservative and progressive assessments of the dynamics of history. He does it with the help of both the narrator’s comments and digressions, often constructed as a talk between a historian, an expert in the times under analysis, and a reader, and the central images of the novels. For the ideological and artistic wholeness of the works, the collective images of Liege and Perth, presented by means of a ‘general plan’ and bright individualized images of citizens, are fundamentally important. Colourful and at the same time super important for the historisophical idea of the novels are the images of the ‘outgoing class’ – chivalry: in each of them, the degree of ‘falling out’ of the dynamics of history is emphasized and becomes character-forming. At the same time, the article accentuates, especially in The Fair Maid of Perth, the author’s idea of changing not only economic but also moral leader in the late Middle Ages: the defining role is gradually passed on to the townspeople. In this respect, the image of Catharine Glover, the titular heroine, acts in the novel as the writer’s ‘Reasoner’. The article also traces the nature of the coexistence of romantic and adventurous (in relation to the novel about Perth – romantic and Gothic) and socio-psychological principles of creating the ‘image of the era’.References
Gorod v srendnevekovoy tsivilizatzii Zapadnoy Evropy. Chelovek vnutri gorodskikh sten. Formirovanie obschestvennykh svyazey [Town in the Medieval Civilization of the Western Europe. A Man Within Town Walls. Formation of Social Ties]. Ed. by A. A. Svanidze. Moscow, Nauka Publ., 2000, vol. 3, 378 p. (In Russ.)
Gorod v srendnevekovoy tsivilizatzii Zapadnoy Evropy. Chelovek vnutri gorodskikh sten. Extra muros: gorod, obschestvo, gosudarstvo [Town in the Medieval Civilization of the Western Europe. A Man Within Town Walls. Extra Muros: Town, Society, State]. Ed. by A. A. Svanidze. Moscow, Nauka Publ., 2004, vol. 4. 354 p. (In Russ.)
Lazareva T. G. Antikvarnoe dvizhenie v Britanii XVIII veka i Valter Skott [The antiquarian movement in Britain in the late 18th century and Walter Scott]. Vestnik Permskogo Universiteta. Rossiyskaya i Zarubezhnaya Filologiya [Perm University Herald. Russian and Foreign Philology], 2009, issue 4, pp. 45–50. (In Russ.)
Reizov B. G. Voinstvuyuschiy romantic Ogusten T’erri. 6 glava [Augustin Thierry, a bellicose romantic. Chapter 6]. Reizov B. G. Frantsuzskaya romanticheskaya istoriografiya. 1815–1830 [French Romantic Historiography. 1815-1830]. Leningrad, Leningrad State University Press, 1956, 536 p. Available at: https://istmat.org/node/39436 (accessed 15 Feb 2022). (In Russ.)
Alexander J. H. The ‘Amanuensis of History’ in Franco-Burgundian Novels. European Romantic Review, 2002, issue 13, pp. 239 – 247. (In Eng.)
Grierson H. J. C. Sir Walter Scott. London, Constable & Co, 1938. XII; 320 p. (In Eng.)
De Groot J. The Historical Novel. London and New York, Routledge, 2010. 200 p. (In Eng.)
Delvin D. D. Scott and history. Scott’s Mind and Art. Ed. by A. Norman Jeffares. Edinburgh, Oliver & Boyd, 1969, pp. 72 – 92. (In Eng.)
Dennison E. P. The Evolution of Scotland’s Towns. Creation, Growth and Fragmentation. Edinburgh, Edinburgh University Press, 2017. 256 p. (In Eng.)
Edwards S. The geography of violence: Historical fiction and the national question. Novel, 2001, issue 34, pp. 294 – 308. (In Eng.)
Hall D. W. Burgess, Merchant and Priest: Burgh Life in the Scottish Medieval Town. Edinburgh, Birlinn Ltd with Historic Scotland, 2002. 56 p. (In Eng.)
Kerr J. Fiction against History: Scott as a Storyteller. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1989. 170 p. (In Eng.)
Lynch M., Spearman M., Steel. The Scottish Medieval Town. Edinburgh, J. Donald, 1988. 366 p. (In Eng.)
Peardon T. P. The Transition in English Historical Writing, 1760 – 1830. New York, Columbia University Press, 1933. 340 p. (In Eng.)
Raleigh J. H. ‘Waverley’ and ‘The Fair Maid of Perth’. Some British Romantics: A Collection of Essays. Ed. by James Logan. Columbus, Ohio State University Press, 1966, pp. 235–266. (In Eng.)
Rubenstein J. The defeat and triumph of bourgeois pacifism: Scott’s Fair Maid of Perth and the Fortunes of Nigel. The Wordsworth Circle, 1971, issue 2, pp. 135–141. (In Eng.)
Scott W. The Fair Maid of Perth, or Saint Valentine Day. Available at: https://www.gutenberg.org/files/7987/7987-h/7987-h.htm (accessed 15 Feb 2022). (In Eng.)
Scott W. Quentin Durward. Available at: https://www.gutenberg.org/files/7853/7853-h/7853-h.htm (accessed 15 Feb 2022). (In Eng.)
Shaw H. E. The Form of Historical Fiction. Ithaca and London, Cornell University Press, 1983. 272 p. (In Eng.)
Spencer M. Quentin Durward and Lois XI: Sir Walter Scott as historian. Depriving Neo-Medievalism. Ed. by Karl Fugelso. New York, D. S. Brewer, 2011, pp. 43–59. (In Eng.)
Young G. M. Scott and the historians. Sir Walter Scott Lectures, 1940 – 1948. Ed. by H. J. C. Grierson. With an introduction of Professor W. L. Renwick. Edinburgh, University of Edinburgh, 1950, pp. 79–108. (In Eng.)
Список литературы
Город в средневековой цивилизации Западной Европы. Человек внутри городских стен. Формирование общественных связей / ред. А. А. Сванидзе. М.: Наука, 2000. Т. 3. 378 с.
Город в средневековой цивилизации Западной Европы. Человек внутри городских стен. Extra muros: город, общество, государство / ред. А. А. Сванидзе. М.: Наука, 2004. Т. 4. 354 с.
Лазарева Т. Г. Антикварное движение в Британии XVIII века и Вальтер Скотт // Российская и зарубежная филология. Вестник Пермского университета. 2009. Вып. 4. С. 45–50.
Реизов Б. Г. Воинствующий романтик Огюстен Тьерри. 6 глава // Реизов Б. Г. Французская романтическая историография. 1815–1830. Л.: Ленингр. гос. ун-т, 1956. 536 c. URL: https://istmat.org/node/39436 (дата обращения: 15.02.2022)
Alexander J. H. The ‘Amanuensis of History’ in Franco-Burgundian Novels // European Romantic Review. 2002. № 13. P. 239–247.
Grierson H. J. C. Sir Walter Scott. London: Constable & Co, 1938. XII; 320 p.
De Groot J. The Historical Novel. London and New York: Routledge, 2010. 200 p.
Delvin D. D. Scott and History // Scott’s Mind and Art. Edited by A. Norman Jeffares. Edinburgh: Oliver & Boyd, 1969. P. 72–92.
Dennison E. P. The Evolution of Scotland’s Towns. Creation, Growth and Fragmentation. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 2017. 256 p.
Edwards S. The Geography of Violence: Historical Fiction and the National Question // Novel. 2001. № 34. P. 294–308.
Hall D.W. Burgess, Merchant and Priest: Burgh Life in the Scottish Medieval Town. Edingburgh: Birlinn Ltd with Historic Scotland, 2002. 56 p.
Kerr J. Fiction against History: Scott as a Storyteller. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989. 170 p.
Lynch M., Spearman M., Steel G. The Scottish Medieval Town. Edinburgh: J. Donald, 1988. 366 p.
Peardon T. P. The Transition in English Historical Writing, 1760–1830. New York: Columbia University Press, 1933. 340 p.
Raleigh J. H. ‘Waverley’ and ‘The Fair Maid of Perth’ // Some British Romantics: A Collection of Essays. Edited by James Logan. Columbus: Ohio State University Press, 1966. P. 235–266.
Rubenstein J. The Defeat and Triumph of Bourgeois Pacifism: Scott’s Fair Maid of Perth and the Fortunes of Nigel // The Wordsworth Circle. 1971. № 2. P. 135–141.
Scott W. The Fair Maid of Perth, or Saint Valentine Day. URL: https://www.gutenberg.org/files/7987/7987-h/7987-h.htm (дата обращения: 15.02.2022)
Scott W. Quentin Durward. URL: https://www.gutenberg.org/files/7853/7853-h/7853-h.htm (дата обращения: 15.02.2022)
Shaw H.E. The Form of Historical Fiction. Ithaca and London: Cornell University Press, 1983. 272 p.
Spencer M. Quentin Durward and Lois XI: Sir Walter Scott as Historian // Depriving Neo-medievalism. Edited by Karl Fugelso. New York: D.S. Brewer, 2011. P. 43–59.
Young G. M. Scott and the Historians // Sir Walter Scott Lectures, 1940 – 1948. Edited by H. J. C. Grierson. With an Introduction of Professor W. L. Renwick. Edinburgh: University of Edinburgh, 1950. P. 79–108.
