Soviet-style Orientalism: Combatant’s Memories about Afghanistan War
Keywords:
oral history, veterans of local conflicts, orientalism, hybrid identities, narratives, practices of commemoration,Abstract
The article is based on the diaries and semi-formalized interviews of Russian participants of the Afghanistan war of 1979-1989. Two modalities of their attitudes towards local realities are considered. On the one hand, the locals are described as the representatives of the "backward" eastern country, left in the Middle Ages. On the other hand, such "orientalisation" does not hamper a whole network of pragmatic interactions and (semi)capitalist exchange between Afghans and "shuravi". Sometimes, this "business" even causes the effect of "self-orientalisation" of internationalist soldiers who described themselves as "savages" affected by the consumer abundance of Afghan "ducans". As a result, the "self" / "alien" opposition, on the one hand, is proclaimed to be the basis for self-identification of veterans. On the other hand, it proves to be quite mobile and situational, generating numerous paradoxes. The practices of “from the bottom-up” collective survival further complicate this picture. In the everyday reality of military life, the "backward" Afghan Other splits into "useful" and "useless" Other. The first is largely "humanized" and described using an "internationalist" dictionary. Orientalist clichés are preserved here, but the notorious "Eastern specificity" begins to play the role not of the stigma of "savagery", but rather of an aesthetically interesting "ornament". The "useless" Other remains shrouded in a dense veil of orientalist formulas. All these modalities and symbolic meanings do not fit well together, forming zones of some tension - this "hybrid" identity is constantly being revised. In this context, the main task of oral history and war anthropology is to clarify the mechanisms and functions of such an "assemblage".doi 10.17072/2219-3111-2018-4-50-58References
Библиографический список
Козлова Н.Н. Сцены из частной жизни периода «застоя»: семейная переписка // Журнал социологии и социальной антропологии. 1999. No 3. С. 120–133.
Кузьмин Н.М. Войсковые разведчики в Афгане: Записки начальника разведки дивизии. М.: Яуза, Эксмо, 2013. 320 с.
Лапшин Ю.М. Афганский дневник М.: ОЛМА-ПРЕСС Образование, 2004. 447 с.
Николаи Ф.В., Кобылин И.И. Американские traumastudies и проблемы их транзитивности в России // Логос. 2017. No 5. С. 115–136.
Орлов А.Н. Дневник пехотного лейтенанта. М.: ВегаПринт, 2014. 224 с.
Сенявская Е.С. Противники России в войнах ХХ века. М.: РОCСПЭН, 2006. 288 с.
Стародымов Н.А. Боевой дневник афганской войны. М.: Яуза, Эксмо, 2009. 384 с.
Хархордин О., Волков В. Теория практик. СПб.: Изд-во Европ. ун-та, 2008. 298 с.
Kaldor M. New and Old Wars: Organized Violence in a Global Era. Stanford University Press, 2012. 256 p.
Murray W., Mansoor P.R. Hybrid Warfare: Fighting Complex Opponents from the Ancient World to the Present. Cambridge University Press, 2012. 334 p.
Oushakine S. A. Presence without Identification: Vicarious Photography and Postcolonial Figuration in Belarus // October. 2018. Is. 164. P. 49–88.
References
Kaldor, M. (2012), New and Old Wars: Organized Violence in a Global Era, Stanford University Press, Redwood City, USA, 256 p.
Kozlova, N.N. (1999), “Scenes from the private life of the "stagnation" period: family correspondence”, Journal of Sociology and Social Anthropology, No 3, pp. 120-133.
Kuzmin, N.M. (2013), Voyskovye razvedchiki v Afgane. Zapiski nachalnika razvedki divizii [Army scouts in Afghanistan. Notes of the intelligence division chief], Eksmo, Moscow, Russia, 320 p.
Lapshin, Yu.M. (2004), Afganskiy dnevnik [Afghan diary], Obrazovanie, Moscow, Russia, 447 p.
Murray, W. & P.R. Mansoor (2012), Hybrid Warfare: Fighting Complex Opponents from the Ancient World to the Present, Cambridge University Press, New York, USA, 334 p.
Nikolai, F.V. & I.I. Kobylin (2017), “American trauma studies and problems of their transitivity in Russia”, Logos, No 5, pp. 115-136.
Orlov, A.N. (2014), Dnevnik pekhotnogo leytenanta [Infantry lieutenant's diary], Vega Print, Moscow, Russia, 224 p.
Oushakine, S.A. (2018), “Presence without identification: vicarious photography and postcolonial figuration in Belarus”, October, iss. 164, pp. 49-88.
Senyavskaya, E.S. (2006), Protivniki Rossii v voynah ХХ veka [Opponents of Russia in wars of the 20th century], ROSSPEN, Moscow, Russia, 288 p.
Starodymov, N.A. (2009), Boevoy dnevnik afganskoy voyny [Combat diary of the Afghan war], Eksmo, Moscow, Russia, 384 p.