British pre-revolutionary parliament in modern (XX century), the English-language historiography
Keywords:
Britain, Parliament, historiography, W. Notestein, C. RussellAbstract
The paper is devoted to the study of English-language historiography pre-revolutionary British parliament. Chronological framework - XX century. Problems associated with the study of the formation of the legal community in Europe, and in England in particular, most clearly traced by the example of the English-speaking historians debate on the nature of pre-revolutionary parliamentary debate sessions. Throughout the 20th century representation of the pre-revolutionary England and the role of Parliament in the opposition movement is constantly changing. From critical areas to the "Whig" position Neale J.E., from discussions liberals ("Whigs") and Marxist to the "revisionism" 1960-70s. headed by Geoffrey Elton and Conrad Russell and appearance postrevizionizm in which there is still no consensus about the origins of the English Revolution and the role of Parliament in Crisis 1640s. A thorough study of sources, many of which have been systematized and published it throughout the century XX, has put the scientific community to rethink its predecessors. Began to appear studies comparing model representation in Europe and America. For example, in 2007 a conference was held under the auspices of the Yale Center for Parliamentary History "Peoples, Powers and parliaments", dedicated to the comparative analysis of models of representation in Europe and America in the early modern times. In addition, an important role in such discussions plays the emergence of new methodological approaches in the historical science that can be applied successfully to the emerging new material. Bearing in mind the lack of translation into Russian language of the sources, a review of research in the original language is of utmost importance.References
Библиографический список
Кондратьев С.В. Английская революция XVII в. М., 2010.
Репина Л.П. От «спора о джентри» к истории народной культуры: социальные аспекты в интерпретациях английской революции // Репина Л.П. Новая историческая наука и социальная история. М., 1998.
Репина Л.П. От «спора о джентри» к «новому консенсусу»: неолиберальные и неоконсервативные концепции английской революции // Английская революция середины XVII в. (К 350-летию). М., 1991.
Сидорова Т.А. Формирование и развитие критического направления в английской историографии конца XIX – начала XX в.: дис. … док.ист.наук. Казань, 2004.
Burgess G. Absolute Monarchy and the Stuart Constitution. New Haven; London, 1996.
Burgess G. British Political Thought, 1500–1660. The Politics of the рost-Reformation. New York, 2009.
Cogswell T.A. Low Road to Extinction. Supply and Redress of Grievances in the Parliaments of the 1620 // HJ. 1990. Vol. 33, No. 2.
Collinson P. The Monarchical Republic of Queen Elizabeth I // Elizabethan Essayes. London, 1994.
Commons Debates for 1629 / ed. by W. Notestein, F.H. Relf. Minneapolis, 1921.
Commons Debates, 1621 / ed. by W. Notestein, F.H. Relf, H. Simpson. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1935.
Curst R., Hughes A. Introduction: After Revisionism // Conflict in Early Stuart England / еd. by R. Curst, A. Hughes. London, 1989.
Curst R., Hughes A. [Introduction] // The English Civil War / еd. by R. Curst, A. Hughes. London, 1997.
Elton G.R. Policy and Police: The Enforcement of the Reformation in the Age of Thomas Cromwell. Cambridge, 1972.
Elton G.R. Tudor Government: The Points of Contact. I. Parliament // TRHS. 5th ser. 1974. Vol. 24.
Foster E.R. The House of Lords, 1603–1649. Structure, Procedure and the Nature of Its Business. Chapel Hill; London, 1983.
Graves M.A.R. The Tudor House of Lords in the reigns of Edward VI and Mary I: Ph D Thesis. Otago, 1974.
Gruenfelder J.K. Influence in Early Stuart Election, 1604–1640. Columbus, 1981.
Guy J. Monarchy and Counsel: Models of the State // The Sixteenth Century / ed. by Collinson P. Oxford, 2002.
Hart J. S. Justice upon Petition: The House of Lords and the Reformation of Justice, 1621–1675. London, 1991.
Hartley T.E. Elizabeth`s Parliaments: Queen, Lords and Commons, 1559–1601. Manchester, 1992.
Hill C. Parliament and People in Seventeenth - Century England // P&P. 1981. No 92.
Hirst D. Revisionism Revised: Two Perspectives on Early Stuart Parliamentary History: The Place of Principle // P&P. 1981. Vol. 92.
Hexter J.H. Power Struggle, Parliament and Liberty in Early Stuart England // Journal Modern History. 1978. № 50.
Hexter J.H. Storm over the Gentry. The Tawney – Trevor-Roper Controversy// Encounter. 1958. № 5, May.
Hutton R. Debates in Stuart History. Basingstoke; New York, 2004.
Kishlansky M.A. Parliamentary Selection: Social and Political Choice in Early Modern England. Cambridge, 1986.
Loach J. Parliament under the Tudors. Oxford, 1991.
Mears N. Queenship and Political Discourse in the Elizabethan Realms. Cambridge, 2005.
Neale J.E. The Biographical approach to History // History. 1951. Vol.36.
Neale J.E. Elizabeth I and her Parliaments: 2 vols. London, 1953, 1957.
Notestein W. The Winning of the Initiative by the House of Commons. New Haven, 1924.
Pears, Politics and Power. The House of Lords, 1603–1640 / ed. by C. Jones, D.L. Jones. London, 1986.
Peltonen M. Classical Humanism and Republicanism in English Political Thought 1570–1640. Сambridge, 1995.
McLaren A.N. Political Culture in the Reign of Elizabeth I. Queen and Commonwealth 1558–1585. Cambridge, 1999.
Rabb T.K. Revisionism Revised: Two Perspectives on Early Stuart Parliamentary History: The Role of the Commons // P&P. 1981. Vol. 92.
Realities of Representation. State Building in Early Modern Europe and European America / еd. by M. Jansson. New York; Basingstoke,2007.
Russell C. The Crisis of Parliaments: English History, 1509–1660. Oxford, 1971.
Russell C. Parliamentary History in Perspective, 1604–1629 // History. 1976. Vol. 61, No. 201.
Russell C. Parliaments and English Politics, 1621–1629. Oxford, 1979.
Russell C. The Nature of a Parliament in Early Stuart England // Before the English Civil War / ed. by H. Tomlinson. London, 1983.
Sharpe K. Sir Robert Cotton, 1586–1631: History and Politics in Early Modern England. Oxford, 1979.
Sharpe K. Politics and Ideas in Early Stuart England: Essays and Studies. London, 1989.
Smith D.L. The Stuart Parliaments. 1603–1689. London, 1999.
Sommerville J.P. Politics and Ideology in England, 1603–1640. London, 1986.
Stacy W.R. Impeachment, Attainder, and the «Revival» of Parliamentary Judicature under the Early Stuarts // PH. 1992. Vol. 11.
Stone L. The Revival of Narrative: Reflection on a New Old History// P&P. 1979. Vol. 85.
Tyacke N. Wroth, Cecil and the Parliamentary Session of 1604// BIHR. 1977. Vol.50.
References
Kondratev S.V. Angliyskaya revolyutsiya XVII veka. Moscow, 2000. P. 7-11. (?)
Repina L.P. Ot «spora o dzhentri» istorii narodnoi kultury: sotsialnye aspekty v interpritatsiyakh angliyskoi revolutsii. Repina L.P. «Novaya istoricheskaya nauka i sotsialnaya istoria». Moscow, 1998. P. 73-118.
Repina L.P. Ot «spora o dzhentri» k «novomu konsensusu»: neoliberalnye I neokonservativnye kontseptsii angliyskoi revolutsii. Angliyskaya revolyutsiya serediny XVII v. (K 350-letiyu). Moscow, 1991. P. 39-83.
Sidorova T.A. Formirovanie i razvitie kriticheskogo napravleniya v angliyskoi istoriografii kontsa XIX – nachala XX veka: dis. … dok.ist.nauk / T.A. Sidorova. – Kazan, 2004. – 441 p.
Burgess G. Absolute Monarchy and the Stuart Constitution. New Haven, L., 1996. 564 p.
Burgess G. British Political Thought, 1500-1660. The Politics of the Post-Reformation. N.Y., 2009. 240 p.
Cogswell T.A. Low Road to Extinction? Supply and Redress of Grievances in the Parliaments of the 1620. HJ. Vol. 33. No. 2. 1990. P. 283-303.
Collinson P. The Monarchical Republic of Queen Elizabeth I. Idem. Elizabethan Essayes. L., 1994.
Commons Debates for 1629 / Ed. by Notestein W., Relf F.H. Minneapolis. 1921; Commons Debates, 1621 / Ed. by Notestein W., Relf F.H., Simpson H. 7 vols. 1935.
Curst R., Hughes A. Introduction: After Revisionism. Conflict in Early Stuart England / Ed. by Curst R., Hughes A. L., 1989. P. 1-47.
Curst R., Hughes A. [Introduction]. The English Civil War / Ed. by Curst R., Hughes A. L., 1997.
Elton G.R. Policy and Police: The Enforcement of the Reformation in the Age of Thomas Cromwell. Cam-bridge. 1972.
Elton G.R. Tudor Government: The Points of Contact. I. Parliament. TRHS. 5th ser. Vol. 24. 1974. Pp. 183-200.
Foster E.R. The House of Lords, 1603-1649. Structure, Procedure, and the Nature of Its Business. Chapel Hill, London. 1983.
Graves M.A.R. The Tudor House of Lords in the reigns of Edward VI and Mary I. Ph D Thesis. Otago. 1974. Неопубликованная докторская диссертация.
Gruenfelder J.R. Influence in Early Stuart Election, 1604-1640. Columbus. 1981.
Guy J. Monarchy and Counsel: Models of the State. The Sixteenth Century / Ed. by Collinson P. Oxford. 2002. P. 113-142.
Hart J. S. Justice upon Petition: The House of Lords and the Reformation of Justice, 1621-1675. L., 1991.
Hartley T.E. Elizabeth`s Parliaments: Queen, Lords and Commons, 1559-1601. Manchester. 1992.
Hill C. Parliament and People in Seventeenth - Century England. P&P. No 92. 1981. P. 100-124.
Hirst D. Revisionism Revised: Two Perspectives on Early Stuart Parliamentary History: The Place of Principle // P&P. Vol. 92. 1981. P. 79-99.
Hexter J.H. Power Struggle, Parliament and Liberty in Early Stuart England. Journal Modern History. 1978. № 50.
Hexter J.H. Storm over the Gentry. The Tawney – Trevor-Roper Controversy. Encounter. May 1958, № 5.
Hutton R. Debates in Stuart History. Basingstoke and New York: Palgrave, 2004. 239 p.
Kishlansky M.A. Parliamentary Selection: Social and Political Choice in Early Modern England. Cambridge. 1986.
Loach J. Parliament under the Tudors. Oxford. 1991.
Mears N. Queenship and Political Discourse in the Elizabethan Realms. Cambridge. 2005.
Neale J.E. The Biographical approach to History. P. 233.
Neale J.E. Elizabeth I and her Parliaments. 2 vols. L., 1953, 1957.
Notestein W. The Winning of the Initiative by the House of Commons. New Haven. 1924.
Pears, Politics and Power. The House of Lords., 1603-1640 / Ed. by Jones C., Jones D.L. L., 1986.
Peltonen M. Classical Humanism and Republicanism in English Political Thought; McLaren A.N. Political Cul-ture in the Reign of Elizabeth I. Queen and Commonwealth 1558-1585. Cambridge. 1999.
Rabb T.K. Revisionism Revised: Two Perspectives on Early Stuart Parliamentary History: The Role of the Commons // P&P. Vol. 92. 1981. P. 55-78.
Realities of Representation. State Building in Early Modern Europe and European America / Ed. by Jansson M. N.Y., Basingstoke. 2007.
Russell C. The Crisis of Parliaments: English History, 1509-1660. Oxford. 1971.
Russell C. Parliamentary History in Perspective, 1604-1629. History. Vol. 61. No. 201. 1976. P. 1-27.
Russell C. Parliaments and English Politics, 1621-1629. Oxford. 1979.
Russell C. The Nature of a Parliament in Early Stuart England. Before the English Civil War / Ed. by Tomlinson H. L., 1983. P. 123-150.
Sharpe K. Sir Robert Cotton, 1586-1631: History and Politics in Early Modern England. Oxford. 1979.
Sharpe K. Politics and Ideas in Early Stuart England: Essays and Studies. L., 1989.
Smith D.L. The Stuart Parliaments. 1603-1689. L., 1999.
Sommerville J.P. Politics and Ideology in England, 1603-1640. L., 1986.
Stacy W.R. Impeachment, Attainder, and the “Revival” of Parliamentary Judicature under the Early Stuarts. PH. Vol. XI. 1992. P. 40-56.
Stone L. The Revival of Narrative: Reflection on a New Old History. P&P. Vol. 85. 1979. P. 3-24.
Tyacke N. Wroth, Cecil and the Parliamentary Session of 1604. BIHR. Vol.50. 1977.P. 120-125.
