THE IDIOM “CIVIL WAR” IN THE POLITICAL RHETORIC OF LEV TROTSKY, 1914–1918
* This material was produced BY REZNIK ALEKSANDR VALERIEVICH, a participant of the «Russian Socialist Movement» (RSD) included in the register of foreign agents.
Keywords:
Russian Civil War, the 1917 Revolution, propaganda, violence legitimization, TrotskyAbstract
This article examines the ways in which Leon Trotsky conceptualized and employed the concept of “civil war” in the period between 1914 and 1918. The idiomatic features of using this concept are significant for understanding the political context of the period of world wars and revolutions, as well as the role of individual leaders in shaping the authoritative language of political communication. By undertaking a comprehensive and continuous analysis of Trotsky's writings, it is possible to reconstruct the key stages through which the term “civil war” evolved in the context of ideological debates that took place between 1914 and 1916, and in the political conflicts that unfolded between 1917 and 1918. Trotsky consistently upheld the Marxist notion of the “class” nature of “civil wars”. Like Lenin, he employed the term in its conventional sense, referencing internal strife and underscoring its deleterious outcomes. He revised his initial negative stance on the “slogan” of civil war, underscoring the “fact” of the ongoing civil war. During periods of armed conflict, Trotsky significantly contributed to the sacralization of civil war as a “sacred” war. Trotsky's rhetoric regarding the representation of the “civil” war was characterized by imagery rather than conceptual innovation.References
Атнашев Т., Велижев М. «Context is King»: Джон Покок ‒ историк политических языков // Новое литературное обозрение. 2015. № 4. С. 21–44.
Бурдье П. Биографическая иллюзия // Интеракция. Интервью. Интерпретация. 2002. Т. 1, № 1. С. 75–84.
Ганин А. В. Русский офицерский корпус в годы Гражданской войны. Противостояние командных кадров. 1917–1922 гг. М.: Центрполиграф, 2019.
Годунов К.В. «Красная Пасха»: празднование годовщин Октября и политическая культура Граж-данской войны. СПб.: Изд-во Европ. ун-та в С.-Петербурге, 2023. 256 с.
Киршин Ю.Я. Лев Троцкий ‒ военный теоретик. Клинцы: Изд-во Клинцов. город. тип., 2003. 335 с.
Колоницкий Б.И., Годунов К.В. «Корниловщина» как «гражданская война»: использование поня-тия в условиях политического кризиса // Вестник Перм. ун-та. История. 2021. Вып. 3(54). С. 78–87.
Резник А.В.* Введение // Л.Д. Троцкий: pro et contra, антология. 2-е изд., испр. / сост., вступ. статья, коммент. А. В. Резника. СПб.: РХГА, 2017. 864 с.
Резник А.В.* Риторика репрезентации гражданской войны в «Известиях» (октябрь 1917 – январь 1918 г.) // Вестник Перм. ун-та. История. 2021. Вып. 3(54). С. 88–100.
Слова и конфликты: язык противостояния и эскалация гражданской войны в России: сб. ст. / под ред. Б.И. Колоницкого [и др.]. СПб.: Изд-во Европ. ун-та в С.-Петербурге, 2022. 328 с.
Шумяков Р.А. «Кронштадтская республика»: дискуссии мая 1917 г. и культурная подготовка гражданской войны в России // Historia provinciae – журнал региональной истории. 2025. № 3. В печати.
Эннкер Б. Формирование культа Ленина в Советском Союзе. М.: РОССПЭН, 2011. 437 с.
Albert G. The Charisma of World Revolution. Revolutionary Internationalism in Early Soviet Society, 1917–1927. Leiden; Boston: Brill, 2023. 569 p.
Gallie W.B. Essentially Contested Concepts // Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society New Series. 1956. Vol. 56. P. 167–198.
Hunt L. Politics, Culture, and Class in the French Revolution. Berkeley; Los Angeles; London: University of California Press, 1984. 251 p.
Knei-Paz B. The Social and Political Thought of Leon Trotsky. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1978. 629 p.
Lih L. T. Bread and Authority in Russia, 1914-1921. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1990
Reznik A.V.* Lev Trotskii as the Mirror of the Russian Revolution // Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History. 2016. Vol. 17. P. 181‒191.
Wortman R. The Power of Language and Rhetoric in Russian Political History: Charismatic Words from the 18th the 21st Centuries. London; New York: Bloomsbury Academic, 2017. 256 p.
References
Albert, G. (2023), The Charisma of World Revolution. Revolutionary Internationalism in Early Soviet Society, 1917–1927, Brill, Leiden, Netherlands, 569 p.
Atnashev, T. & M. Velizhev (2015), “«Context is King»: John Pocock is a historian of political languages”, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, № 4, pp. 21–44.
Bourdieu, P. (2002), “The Biographical illusion”, Interaktsiya. Interv’yu. Interpretatsiya, vol. 1, № 1, pp. 75–84.
Ennker, B. (2011), Formirovanie kul'ta Lenina v Sovetskom Soyuze [The forming of the cult of Lenin in the Soviet Union], ROSSPEN, Moscow, Russia, 437 p.
Gallie, W.B. (1956), “Essentially Contested Concepts”, Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society New Series, vol. 56, pp. 167–198.
Ganin, A.V. (2019), Russkiy ofitserskiy korpus v gody Grazhdanskoy voyny. Protivostoyanie komandnyh kadrov. 1917–1922 gg. [The Russian officer Corps during the Civil War. The confrontation of command personnel. 1917—1922], Tsentrpoligraf, Moscow, Russia, 350 p.
Godunov, K.V. (2023), “Krasnaya Paskha”: prazdnovanie godovshchin Oktyabrya i politicheskaya kul'tura Grazhdanskoy voyny [“Red Easter”: Celebrating the Anniversaries of October and the Political Culture of the Civil War], Izdatel'stvo Evropeyskogo universiteta v Sankt-Peterburge, St. Petersburg, Russia, 256 p.
Hunt, L. (1984), Politics, Culture, and Class in the French Revolution, University of California Press, Berkeley, USA, 251 p.
Knei-Paz, B. (1978), The Social and Political Thought of Leon Trotsky, Clarendon Press, Oxford, UK, 629 p.
Kolonitskii, B.I. & K.V. Godunov (2021), “«Kornilovshchina» as a «civil war»: the application of the concept in the context of a political crisis”, Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Seriya Istoriya, № 3, pp. 78–87.
Kolonitskii, B.I. (ed.), Slova i konflikty: yazyk protivostoyaniya i eskalatsiya grazhdanskoy voyny v Rossii [Words and Conflicts: The Language of Confrontation and the Escalation of the Russian Civil War], Izdatel'stvo Evropeyskogo universiteta v Sankt-Peterburge, St. Petersburg, Russia, 328 p.
Lih, L.T. (1990), Bread and Authority in Russia, 1914-1921, University of California Press, Berkeley, USA, 303 p.
Reznik, A.V.* (2016), “Lev Trotskii as the Mirror of the Russian Revolution”, Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History, vol. 17, pp. 181‒191.
Reznik, A.V.* (2017), “Introduction”, in Reznik, A.V. (ed.), L.D. Trotskiy: pro et contra, antologiya [L.D. Trotsky: pro et contra, an anthology], RKHGA, St. Petersburg, Russia, pp. 7–40.
Reznik, A.V. (2021), “Representation rhetoric of the Civil war in «Izvestia» (October 1917 – January 1918)”, Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Seriya Istoriya, vol. 3, № 54, pp. 88–100.
Shumyakov, R.А. (2025), “«The Kronstadt Republic»: Discussions of May 1917 and the Cultural Preparations for the Civil War in Russia”, Historia Provinciae – Zhurnal regional'noy istorii, № 3 (in print).
Wortman, R. (2017), The Power of Language and Rhetoric in Russian Political History: Charismatic Words from the 18th to the 21st Centuries, Bloomsbury Academic, London, UK, 256 p.
