ACTIVITIES OF THE SECRET COMMITTEE: NEW APPROACHES TO SOLVING CONTROVERSIAL ISSUES
Keywords:
Secret Committee, “young friends”, Alexander I, Russian Empire, reform activityAbstract
In the first years of the reign of Alexander I, a Secret Committee (a circle of “young friends”) was created, which had a certain impact on the formation of domestic and foreign policy. Its participants believed that they should focus on studying the state of affairs in the Russian Empire to further prepare and implement the necessary transformations. It was attended by P.A. Stroganov, his cousin N.N. Novosiltsev, V.P. Kochubey and A. Chartorizhsky. Under the influence of the Secret Committee, Alexander I carried out part of the reforms in the early 19th century. However, the “young friends” acted unofficially and with a certain degree of secrecy. Therefore, there was no official records management of its meetings. These factors will later lead to the emergence of different points of view regarding the activities of the Secret Committee. The authors of the article pursue several goals: to determine the chronological framework for the existence of the Secret Committee, the composition and goals of the Committee, to identify its place in the political system of the Alexander era, to establish its role in the balance of power in court circles, and to evaluate its activities. Sources and the currently existing literature on the Secret Committee were analyzed to reveal these goals. The authors conclude that the upper limit of the activities of the Secret Committee should be increased at least until 1805, and the lower limit should be considered not the first meeting on June 24, 1801, but the activities of the “young friends” circle in 1797–1799 as a kind of preparatory stage. According to the authors, Alexander I, who chaired its meetings and set the agenda, as well as F. La Harpe as a kind of associate member, should be included in the Secret Committee. On the question of the place of the Secret Committee in the alignment of political forces in court circles, the authors state that the Secret Committee played a dual role. On the one hand, it was a new “command” and support for the young emperor, created to develop and conduct serious political and social reforms, and at the same time served as a kind of barrier against attempts by “conspirators” and part of the Catherine's old men, led by G.R. Derzhavin, to limit the supreme power in aristocratic interests. After analyzing the list of events held by the Secret Committee, it was found that its activities were not inconclusive, although for a number of reasons not all of the plans were implemented.References
Арискина Ю.Э. Негласный Комитет и его деятельность: дис. … канд. ист. наук. М., 2015. 364 с.
Богданович М.И. История царствования императора Александра I и Россия в его время. СПб.: Тип. Ф. Сущинского, 1869. Т. I. 382 с.
Валлоттон А. Александр I. М.: Прогресс, 1991. 397 с.
Вел. кн. Николай Михайлович. Граф Павел Александрович Строганов (1774−1817). Исто-рическое исследование эпохи Александра I. СПб.: Экспедиция заготовления гос. бумаг, 1903. Т. II. 386 с.
Вел. кн. Николай Михайлович. Император Александр I. СПб.: Экспедиция заготовления гос. бумаг, 1912. Т. 1. 636 с.
Градовский А.Д. Высшая администрация России XVIII столетия и генерал-прокуроры. СПб.: Тип. И. Бочкарева, 1866. 284 с.
Грацианский П.С. Политическая и правовая мысль России второй половины XVIII в. М.: Наука, 1984. 253 с.
Григорович В. Канцлер А.А. Безбородко в связи с событиями его времени. СПб.: Тип. В.С. Балашева, 1879−1880. Т. II. 736 с.
Далин В.М. Первый русский якобинец // Люди и идеи. М.: Наука, 1970. С. 9−21.
Дворниченко А.Ю., Тот Ю.В., Ходяков М.В. История России. М.: Проспект, 2009. 479 с.
Деревянко А.П., Шабельникова Н.А. История России. М.: Проспект, 2011. 557 с.
Демкин А.В. «Дней Александровых прекрасное начало». Внутренняя политика Александра I в 1801−1805 гг. М.: Кучково поле, 2012. 317 с.
Довнар-Запольский М.В. Зарождение министерств в России и указ о правах Сената 8 сен-тября 1802 г. // Из истории общественных течений в России. Киев: Изд. Ив. Ив. Самонен-ко, 1910. 333 с.
Долгих А.Н. «Увижу ль, о друзья, народ неугнетенный…»: российское дворянство и кре-стьянский вопрос в XVIII – 1-й четверти XIX вв. Историографические очерки. Липецк: Изд-во ЛГПУ им. П.П. Семенова-Тян-Шанского, 2018. Т. 2. 358 с.
Захаров В.Ю. Всемилостивейшая грамота, российскому народу жалуемая 1801 г., в кон-тексте развития конституционных идей в России во 2-й пол. XVIII – начале XIX вв. М.: Прометей, 2002. 191 с.
Захаров В.Ю. Эволюция российского абсолютизма в контексте развития конституционных идей в России и Европе во 2-й пол. XVIII – 1-й четверти XIX вв. М.: Изд-во Нац. ин-та бизнеса, 2008. Ч. 1. 512 с.
Захаров В.Ю. Конституционализм как вариант модернизации российского абсолютизма в конце XVIII – 1-й четверти XIX в. // Российская история. 2011. № 6. С. 31−52.
Захаров В.Ю. Российский и зарубежный конституционализм 2-й пол. XVIII – 1-й четверти XIX вв.: опыт сравнительного анализа. М.: Прометей, 2017. Т. II. 646 с.
Захаров В.Ю. Негласный Комитет и дворянское общественное мнение: сотрудничество или конфронтация? // Ключевские чтения − 2020. Народ и власть: материалы междунар. науч. конф. молодых ученых. М.: Спутник+, 2021. С. 145−152.
Зуев М.Н. История России. М.: Юрайт, 2013. 655 с.
Иванова А.А. Система воззрений и деятельность И.П. Пынина в контексте социально-политической истории России на рубеже XVIII−XIX вв.: автореф. дис. …канд. ист. наук. Воронеж, 2019. 24 с.
История СССР с древнейших времен до Великой Октябрьской социалистической револю-ции. М.: Наука, 1967. Т. IV. 743 с.
Минаева Н.В. Правительственный конституционализм и передовое общественное мнение России в начале XIX века. Саратов: Изд-во Саратов. ун-та, 1982. 291 с.
Мироненко С.В. Самодержавие и реформы. Политическая борьба в России в начале XIX в. М.: Наука, 1989. 238 с.
Окунь С.Б. История СССР: 1796−1825. Курс лекций. Л.: Изд-во и тип. Ленингр. гос. ордена Ленина ун-та, 1948. 492 с.
Окунь С.Б. Очерки истории СССР: конец XVIII – первая четверть XIX вв. Л.: Учпедгиз, 1956. 416 с.
Писарькова Л.Ф. Реформы государственного управления 1801−1802 гг.: замыслы и во-площение // Вестник Рос. ун-та дружбы народов (РУДН). История России. 2009. № 4. С. 35−51.
Писарькова Л.Ф. Власть и общество в 1803−1809 гг.: на пути к реформам государственно-го управления 1810−1811 гг. // Российская история. 2011. № 6. С. 52−72.
Предтеченский А.В. Очерки общественно-политической истории России в первой четвер-ти XIX в. М.; Л.: Изд-во акад. наук СССР, 1957. 456 с.
Пресняков А.Е. Александр I. Петербург: Брокгауз-Ефрон, 1924. 188 с.
Приходько М.А. Негласный комитет и разработка административных реформ в России в начале ХIХ века // Тр. ист. факультета С.-Петерб. ун-та. 2012. № 11. С. 119−129.
Пыпин А.Н. Общественное движение в России при Александре I. СПб.: Издание «Вестника Европы», 1871. 487 с.
Рэй М.-П. Александр I / пер. с фр. А.Ю. Петрова и А.Ю. Терещенко. М.: Росспэн, 2013. 494 с.
Сафонов М.М. Протоколы Негласного Комитета // Вспомогательные исторические дисци-плины (ВИД). Л.: Наука, 1976. Вып. VII. С. 191−209.
Сафонов М.М. Проблема реформ в правительственной политике России на рубеже XVIII и XIX вв. Л.: Наука, 1988. 247 с.
Сахаров А.Н. Александр I. М.: Наука, 1998. 287 с.
Филиппова Н.П. Негласный Комитет и проблема реформирования России: автореф. дис. ... канд. ист. наук. Саранск, 2017. 23 с.
Фреде В. Общественное мнение, его облик сверху: Негласный Комитет Александра I // Новое литературное обозрение: теория и история литературы, критика и библиография. 2018. № 3 (151). С. 164−185.
Шильдер Н.К. Император Александр Первый. СПб.: А.С. Суворин, 1897. Т. II. 450 с.
Raeff M. Plans for Political Reform in Imperial Russia. 1732−1905. New Jersey, 1966. 159 р.
References
Ariskina, Yu.E. (2015), Neglasnyy Komitet i ego deyatelnost [Тhe Secret Committee and its activities], PhD dis-sertation, Moscow, Russia, 364 р.
Bogdanovich, M.I. (1869), Istoriya tsarstvovaniya imperatora Aleksandra I i Rossiya v ego vremya [The history of the reign of Emperor Alexander I and Russia in his time], vol. 1, Tipografiya F. Sushchinsky, St. Petersburg, Russia, 382 р.
Dalin, V.M. (1970), “Pervyy russkiy yakobinets”, in Lyudi i idei [People and ideas], Nauka, Moscow, UUSR, pp. 9–21.
Demkin, A.V. (2012), «Dney Aleksandrovykh prekrasnoye nachalo». Vnutrennyaya politika Aleksandra I v 1801–1805 gg. [“The Days of the Alexandrovs are a wonderful beginning”. The internal policy of Alexander I in 1801–1805], Kuchkovo pole, Moscow, Russia, 317 p.
Derevyanko, A.P & N.A. Shabelnikova (2011), Istoriya Rossii [History of Russia], Prospekt, Moscow, Russia, 557p.
Dolgikh, A.N. (2018), «Uvizhu l, o druzya, narod neugnetennyy…»: rossiyskoye dvoryanstvo i krestianskiy vo-pros v XVIII – 1-oy chetverti XIX vv. Istoriograficheskiye ocherki [“Will I see, O friends, the undisturbed peo-ple...”: the Russian nobility and the peasant question in the 18th –1st quarter of the 19th centuries. Historiograph-ical essays], LGPU im. P.P. Semenova-Tyan-Shanskogo, Lipetsk, Russia, vol. 2, 358 p.
Dovnar-Zapolskiy, M.V. (1905), “Zarozhdeniye ministerstv v Rossii i ukaz o pravakh Senata 8 sentyabrya 1802 g.”, in Iz istorii obshchestvennykh techeniy v Rossii [From the history of social movements in Russia], Iz-danie Iv. Iv. Samonenko, Kiev, Russia, pp. 55–116..
Dvornichenko, A.Yu., Tot, Yu.V. & M.V. Khodyakov (2009), Istoriya Rossii [History of Russia], Prospekt, Mos-cow, Russia, 479 p.
Filippova, N.P. (2017), Neglasnyy Komitet i problema reformirovaniya Rossii [The Secret Committee and the problem of reforming Russia], Extended abstract of PhD dissertation, Saransk, Russia, 23 p.
Frede V. (2018), “Public opinion, its appearance from above: The Secret Committee of Alexander I. Translated from the English by G. Besedina”, New Literary Review: theory and History of Literature, Criticism and Bibli-ography, № 3 (151), pp. 164–185.
Gradovskiy, A.D. (1866), Vysshaya administratsiya Rossii XVIII stoletiya i general-prokurory [The Supreme Administration of Russia of the XVIII century and the Prosecutor General], Tipografiy I. Bochkareva, St. Pe-tersburg, Russia, 284 p.
Gratsianskiy, P.S. (1984), Politicheskaya i pravovaya mysl Rossii vtoroy poloviny XVIII v. [Political and legal thought of Russia in the second half of the XVIII century], Zakharov, Nauka, Moscow, USSR, 253 p.
Grigorovich, V. (1879–1880), Kantsler A.A. Bezborodko v svyazi s sobytiyami ego vremeni [Chancellor A.A. Bezborodko in connection with the events of his time], vol. II, Tipografiy V.S. Balasheva, St. Petersburg, Russia, 736 p.
Istoriya SSSR s drevneyshikh vremen do Velikoy Oktyabrskoy sotsialisticheskoy revolyutsii (1967) [The history of the USSR from ancient times to the Great October Socialist Revolution], vol. IV, Nauka, Moscow, USSR, 743 p.
Ivanova, A.A. (2019), Sistema vozzreniy i deyatelnost I.P. Pnina v kontekste sotsialno-politicheskoy istorii Ros-sii na rubezhe XVIII-XIX vv. [I.P. Pnin's system of views and activities in the context of the socio-political history of Russia at the turn of the 18th and 19th centuries], Extended abstract of PhD dissertation, Voronezh, Russia, 24 p.
Minayeva, N.V. (1982), Pravitelstvennyy konstitutsionalizm i peredovoye obshchestvennoye mneniye Rossii v nachale XIX veka [Governmental Constitutionalism and Advanced Public Opinion in Russia in the early 19th century], Izd-vo Saratovskogo universiteta, Saratov, Russia, 291 p.
Mironenko, S.V. (1989), Samoderzhaviye i reformy. Politicheskaya borba v Rossii v nachale XIX v. [Autocracy and reforms. Political struggle in Russia in the early 19th century], Nauka, Moscow, USSR, 238 p.
Okun’, S.B. (1948), Istoriya SSSR: 1796–1825. Kurs lektsiy [History of the USSR: 1796–1825. Course of lec-tures], Izd-vo i tip. Leningr. gos. ordena Lenina un-ta, Leningrad, USSR, 492 p.
Okun’, S.B. (1956), Ocherki istorii SSSR: konets XVIII – pervaya chetvert XIX vv. [Essays on the history of the USSR: the end of the 18th – first quarter of the 19th centuries], Uchpedgiz, Leningrad, USSR, 416 p.
Penezhko, O. (2009), Gorod Chekhov i khramy Chekhovskogo rayona Moskovskoy oblasti [Chekhov and the temples of the Chekhov district of the Moscow region], Tranzit-IKS, Vladimir, Russia, 271 p.
Pisarkova, L.F. (2009), “Reformy gosudarstvennogo upravleniya 1801-1802 gg.: zamysly i voploshcheniye”, Vestnik Rossiyskogo universiteta druzhby narodov (RUDN). Seriya: Istoriya Rossii, № 4, pp. 35–51.
Pisarkova, L.F. (2011), “Vlast i obshchestvo v 1803-1809 gg.: na puti k reformam gosudarstvennogo upravleni-ya 1810-1811 gg.”, Rossiyskaya istoriya, № 6, pp. 52–72.
Predtechenskiy, A.V. (1957), Ocherki obshchestvenno-politicheskoy istorii Rossii v pervoy chetverti XIX v. [Es-says on the socio-political history of Russia in the first quarter of the 19th century], Izd-vo akad. Nauk SSSR, Moskva, Leningrad, USSR, 456 p.
Presnyakov, A.E. (1924), Aleksandr I [Alexander I], Brokgauz-Efron, Petrograd, USSR, 188 p.
Prikhodko, M.A. (2012), “Neglasnyy komitet i razrabotka administrativnykh reform v Rossii v nachale 19th ve-ka”, Trudy Istoricheskogo fakulteta Sankt-Peterburgskogo universiteta, № 11, pp. 119–129.
Pypin, A.N. (1871), Obshchestvennoye dvizheniye pri Aleksandre I [Social movement under Alexander I], Iz-danie «Vestnika Evropy», St. Petersburg, Russia, 487 p.
Raeff, M. (1966), Plans for Political Reform in Imperial Russia, 1732–1905, Prentice-hall, New Jersey, USA, 159 р.
Rey, M.-P. (2013), Aleksandr I [Alexander I], Rosspen, Moscow, Russia, 494 р.
Safonov, M.M. (1976), “Protokoly Neglasnogo Komiteta”, in Vspomogatelnyye istoricheskiye distsipliny (VID) [Auxiliary historical disciplines (AHD)], iss. VII, Nauka, Leningrad, USSR, pp. 191–209.
Safonov, M.M. (1988), Problema reform v pravitelstvennoy politike Rossii na rubezhe XVIII i XIX vv. [The problem of reforms in Russian government Policy at the turn of the 18th and 19th centuries], Nauka, Leningrad, USSR, 247 p.
Sakharov, A.N. (1998), Aleksandr I [Alexander I], Nauka, Moscow, Russia, 287 p.
Shil'der, N.K. (1897), Imperator Aleksandr Pervyy [Emperor Alexander the First], vol. II, A.S. Suvorin, St. Pe-tersburg, Russia, 450 p.
Vallotton, A. (1991), Aleksandr I [Alexander I], Progress, Moscow, Russia, 397 р.
Vel. kn. Nikolay Mikhaylovich (1903), Graf Pavel Aleksandrovich Stroganov (1774–1817). Istoricheskoye is-sledovaniye epokhi Aleksandra I [Count Pavel Alexandrovich Stroganov (1774–1817), Historical research of the era of Alexander I], vol. II, Ekspeditsiya zagotovleniya gos. bumag, St. Petersburg, Russia, 386 р.
Vel. kn. Nikolay Mikhaylovich (1912), Imperator Aleksandr I [Emperor Alexander I], vol. 1, Ekspeditsiya zagotovleniya gos. bumag, St. Petersburg, Russia, 636 p.
Zakharov, V.Yu. & A.N. Ivanova (2016), “Usadby goroda Chekhova (Lopasnya-Zachatyevskoye. Ivanovsko-ye-Sadki. Solnyshkovo) v sravnitelnoy retrospective”, in Istoriya Moskovskogo kraya. Problemy. issledovaniya. novyye materialy [History of the Moscow region. Problems, research, new materials], iss. VI., Moskovskiy gosu-darstvennyy oblastnoy universitet, Moscow, Russia, pp. 254–273.
Zakharov, V.Yu. (2002), Vsemilostiveyshaya gramota rossiyskomu narodu zhaluyemaya 1801 g. v kontekste razvitiya konstitutsionnykh idey v Rossii vo 2-oy pol. XVIII – nachale XIX vv. [The Most Gracious letter, granted to the Russian people in 1801 in the context of the development of constitutional ideas in Russia in the 2nd half of the 18th – early 19th centuries], Prometey, Moscow, Russia, 191 p.
Zakharov, V.Yu. (2008), Evolyutsiya rossiyskogo absolyutizma v kontekste razvitiya konstitutsionnykh idey v Rossii i Evrope vo 2-oy pol. XVIII – 1-oy chetverti XIX vv. Ch.1. [The evolution of Russian Absolutism in the context of the development of constitutional ideas in Russia and Europe in the 2nd half of the 18th – 1st quarter of the 19th centuries], Izd-vo Nats. In-ta biznesa, Moscow, Russia, 512 p.
Zakharov, V.Yu. (2011), “Konstitutsionalizm kak variant modernizatsii rossiyskogo absolyutizma v kontse XVIII – 1-oy chetverti XIX veka”, Rossiyskaya istoriya, № 6, pp. 31–52.
Zakharov, V.Yu. (2017), Rossiyskiy i zarubezhnyy konstitutsionalizm 2-oy pol. XVIII – 1-oy chetverti XIX vv.: opyt sravnitelnogo analiza [Russian and foreign constitutionalism of the 2nd half of the 18th – 1st quarter of the 19th centuries: the experience of comparative analysis], vol. II, Prometey, Moscow, Russia, 646 p.
Zakharov, V.Yu. (2021), “Neglasnyy Komitet i dvoryanskoye obshchestvennoye mneniye: sotrudnichestvo ili konfrontatsiya?”, in Klyuchevskiye chteniya 2020. Narod i vlast. Materialy mezhdunarodnoy nauchnoy kon-ferentsii molodykh uchenykh. Sbornik nauchnykh trudov [Klyuchevskie readings 2020. The people and the gov-ernment. Materials of the international scientific conference of young scientists. Collection of scientific papers], OOO «Izdatel'stvo «Sputnik+», Moscow, Russia, pp. 254–273.
Zuyev, M.N. (2013), Istoriya Rossii [History of Russia], Izdatel'stvo Yurayt, Moscow, Russia, 655 p.
