ON THE ROLE OF GRIGORY ORDZHONIKIDZE IN THE INNER-PARTY STRUGGLE OF THE 1920s
Keywords:
Grigory K. Ordzhonikidze, Joseph V. Stalin, VKP(b), Central Control Commission, Politburo, Central Committee, oppositionAbstract
The article examines the role of Grigory Ordzhonikidze in the inner-party struggle of the 1920s. The purpose of the article is to determine what position Ordzhonikidze held at different stages of the inner-party struggle. The transcripts and other documents of the leadership of the Bolshevik Party, stored in the Russian State Archive of Socio-Political History (RGASPI), became the basis for the research. Contrary to the popular opinion in historiography, the author states that Ordzhonikidze acted independently and was not an obedient satellite of Joseph Stalin during the inner-party struggle. After being appointed the Chairman of the Central Control Commission, he tried to some extent to alleviate the severity of political conflicts and prevent the use of harsh punishments against Stalin's opponents. There is a version in historiography according to which in 1928, during the conflict between Stalin and the Rykov – Bukharin group, Ordzhonikidze initially supported the «right wing» of the Politburo, but then suddenly revised his views and supported Stalin’s position. Based on the analysis of archival documents, the author concludes that this statement is invalid. At the same time, Ordzhonikidze, although he was on friendly terms with Stalin and shared his views on the peasant question had a conciliatory attitude and was inclined to seek a compromise with the «right». Ordzhonikidze's conciliatory attitude disappeared after the Trotskyists published a recording of a secret conversation between N. I. Bukharin and L. B. Kamenev. This compromising material formed among the Bolshevik leadership the perception of the «right wing» of the Politburo as an opposition group capable of splitting the «monolithic unity» of the party. For this reason, at the beginning of 1929, when the supreme party court over the «right» was held at the joint meetings of the Politburo and the Presidium of the Central Control Commission, Ordzhonikidze acted as one of the main accusers.References
Апальков Д.И. Объединенные заседания Политбюро и Президиума ЦКК 30 января и 9 февраля 1929 г. и их значение в истории внутрипартийной борьбы 1920-х гг. // Клио. 2017. № 8. С. 106–113.
Назаров О.Г. Сталин и борьба за лидерство в большевистской партии в условиях НЭПа. М.: ИВИ РАН, 2002. 204 с.
Такер Р. Сталин: Путь к власти. 1879–1929. История и личность. М.: Прогресс, 1990. 480 с.
Фельштинский Ю.Г. Два эпизода из истории внутрипартийной борьбы: конфиденциальные беседы Бухарина // Вопросы истории. 1991. № 2–3. С. 182–198.
Хлевнюк О.В. Сталин и Орджоникидзе. Конфликты в Политбюро в 30-е годы. М.: Россия молодая, 1993. 144 с.
Хлевнюк О.В. Хозяин. Сталин и утверждение сталинской диктатуры. М.: РОССПЭН, 2010. 479 с.
Шубин А.В. Вожди и заговорщики. М.: Вече, 2004. 400 с.
References
Apalkov, D. I. (2017), “Joint Meetings of the Politburo and the Presidium of the Central Control Committee on January 30 and February 9, 1929 and Their Significance in the History of the Inner-party Struggle of the 1920s”, Klio, № 8, pp. 106–113.
Felshtinsky, Yu.G. (1991), “Two Episodes from the History of the Inner-party Struggle: Bukharin's Confidential Conversations”, Voprosy istorii, 1991, № 2–3, pp. 182–198.
Khlevniuk, O.V. (1993), Stalin i Ordzhonikidze. Konflikty v Politbyuro v 30-e gody [Stalin and Ordzhonikidze. Conflicts in the Politburo in the 30s], Rossiya molodaya, Moscow, Russia, 144 p.
Khlevniuk, O.V. (2010), Hozyain. Stalin i utverzhdenie stalinskoj diktatury [The Boss. Stalin and the Establish-ment of the Stalinist Dictatorship], ROSSPEN, Moscow, Russia, 479 p.
Nazarov, O.G. (2002), Stalin i bor'ba za liderstvo v bol'shevistskoy partii v usloviyah NEPa [Stalin and the Struggle for Leadership in the Bolshevik Party in the Conditions of the NEP], IVI RAN, Moscow, Russia, 204 p.
Shubin, A.V. (2004), Vozhdi i zagovorshchiki [Chiefs and Conspirators], Veche, Moscow, Russia, 400 p.
Taker, R. (1990). Stalin: Put' k vlasti. 1879–1929. Istoriya i lichnost' [Stalin: The Path to Power. 1879–1929. History and Personality], Progress, Moscow, Russia, 480 p.
