SIGNS OF THE TIME: MEMORY ABOUT MASS POLITICS OF THE 1990s IN THE EXPOSITIONS OF RUSSIAN MUSEUMS
Keywords:
cultural memory, social memory, memory about the 1990s, museification, mass politicsAbstract
The article explores framing of collective memory about the 1990s in two Russian museums of political history. It provides a comparative analysis of the expositions of the State Central Museum of Contemporary History of Russia (SCMCHR) in Moscow and the Museum of Boris Yeltsin (MBY) in Yeltsin Center in Ekaterinburg, with a focus on material objects representing the mass politics. The comparative analysis of material objects presented in the two museums is supplemented by the observations derived from memoirs of “the ordinary” people. It helps to reconstruct the stories that might be triggered by the objects at display, and to reveal some lacunas and inconsistencies in the expositions. The expositions of SCMCHR and MBY are evidently different, which is determined by their missions and narratives. SCMCHR presents a broader spectrum of political and social perspectives and pays more attention to the negative aspects of the 1990s. The exposition of MBY is focused on the figure of Russia’s first president, who is presented as the leader who brought people freedom. This allows the authors of the exhibition to provide less space for the voices of “ordinary people” and emphasizes positive aspects of the 1990s. In spite of the differences, both expositions provide multidimensional stories that go beyond the stereotypes exploited in political discourses. They illustrate not only the economic difficulties and political turbulences of the 1990s, but also the mass support for the expected changes and new opportunities for social activities. This is particularly true for the case of mass politics, as both expositions provide evidence of political freedoms incomparable to that in Putin’s Russia.References
Абрамов Р.Н., Чистякова А.А. Ностальгические репрезентации позднего советского периода в медиапроектах Л. Парфенова: по волнам коллективной памяти // Международный журнал исследований культуры. 2012. Т. 6, № 1. С. 52−58.
Аникин Д.А. Точка (не)возврата: распад СССР и становление новой России в мемориальном дискурсе РПЦ // Tempus et Memoria. 2021. Т. 2, № 3. С. 27–35.
Ассман А. Длинная тень прошлого: мемориальная культура и историческая политика. М.: Новое литературное обозрение, 2014. 328 с.
Болотников В. Мои 90-е [Электронный ресурс] // Пишем историю сами: портал. URL: https://memory.history90.ru/show/117 (дата обращения: 16.05.2022).
Бонч-Осмоловская А. Имена времени: эпитеты десятилетий в Национальном корпусе русского языка как проекция культурной памяти // Шаги – Steps. 2018. № 4 (3-4). С. 115−146.
Были 90-х. Т. 1. Как мы выживали / авт.-сост. А. Маринина. М.: ЭКСМО-пресс, 2017. 352 с.
Были 90-х. Т. 2. Эпоха лихой святости / авт.-сост. А. Маринина. М.: ЭКСМО-пресс, 2018. 384 с.
Власов Ю.В. Россия 90-х: младореформаторы о первом опыте демократических реформ [Электронный ресурс] // Пишем историю сами: портал. URL: https://memory.history90.ru/show/10 (дата обращения: 16.05.2022).
Гребень О., Агепеева К. Восприятие «девяностых» [Электронный ресурс] // Пресс-выпуск Левада-Центра, 6.04.2020. URL: https://www.levada.ru/2020/04/06/vospriyatie-devyanostyh/ (дата обращения: 16.05.2022).
Коган Д.Л. Лучшие годы российской истории [Электронный ресурс] // Пишем историю сами: портал. URL: https://memory.history90.ru/show/349 (дата обращения: 16.05.2022).
Латов Ю.В. Парадоксы восприятия современными россиянами России времен Л.И. Брежнева, Б.Н. Ельцина и В.В. Путина // Полис. Политические исследования. 2018. № 5. С. 116−133.
Лесневская О.В. Прощай, ХХ век! Гл. 8 [Электронный ресурс] // Пишем историю сами: портал. URL: https://memory.history90.ru/show/366 (дата обращения: 16.05.2022).
Лесневская О.В. Прощай, ХХ век! Гл. 16 [Электронный ресурс] // Пишем историю сами: портал. URL: https://memory.history90.ru/show/374 (дата обращения: 16.05.2022).
Малинова О.Ю. Официальный исторический нарратив как элемент политики идентичности в России: от 1990-х к 2010-м годам // Полис. Политические исследования. 2016. № 6. С. 139−158.
Малинова О.Ю. Обоснование политики 2000-х годов в дискурсе В.В. Путина и формирование мифа о «лихих девяностых» // Политическая наука. 2018. № 3. С. 45−69.
Малинова О.Ю. Конструирование смысловых рамок памяти о реформах 1990-х гг. в либеральном дискурсе 2000-х гг. // Южно-российский журнал социальных наук. 2019. № 3. С. 91−105.
Малинова О.Ю. Тема «лихих девяностых» в дискурсах российских коммунистов и национал-патриотов // Вестник Перм. ун-та. Политология. 2020. Т. 14, № 2. С. 53−63.
Мерзлякова В.Н. Медиатизация коллективной памяти о 1990-х гг. в Рунете // Вестник РГГУ. Литературоведение. Языкознание. Культурология. 2019. № 8. С. 289–302.
Миллер А.И., Малинова О.Ю. После конференции о памяти 1990-х: диалог // Tempus et Memoria. 2021. Т. 2, № 3. С. 6–12.
Мишина Е.А. Путч [Электронный ресурс] // Пишем историю сами: портал. URL: https://memory. history90.ru/show/47 (дата обращения: 16.05.2022).
Никита Михалков против Ельцин Центра: как развивался конфликт [Электронный ресурс] // Сайт ТАСС. 12.12.2016. URL: https://tass.ru/obschestvo/3863882 (дата обращения: 16.05.2022).
Синельникова Е.С., Зиновьева Е.В. Историческая память о 90-х годах XX века в России: психологические аспекты // Вестник Моск. ун-та. Психология. 2018. № 4. С. 74−88.
Сорокин А.И. Из дневника сотрудника Большого театра: Москва 1990−1993 [Электронный ресурс] // Пишем историю сами: портал. URL: https://memory.history90.ru/show/2 (дата обращения: 16.05.2022).
Суслов А.Б., Шуйская Е.В. Школьные учебники о демократическом транзите в России в 1990-е гг. // Известия Алт. гос. ун-та. Исторические науки и археология. 2020. № 6 (116). С. 68−72.
Утехин И.В. Визуальные образы 1990-х в Инстаграме: коммерциализация ностальгии // Tempus et Memoria. 2021. Т. 2, № 3. С. 60–72.
Чернова И.А. Мои девяностые. Часть 1. Время надежд, интересной работы и реальных перемен [Электронный ресурс] // Пишем историю сами: портал. URL: https://memory.his-tory90. ru/show/400 (дата обращения: 16.05.2022).
Энгстрем М. Ресайклинг позднесоветской контркультуры и новая эстетика «второго мира» // Новое литературное обозрение. 2021. № 3. С. 70−88.
Яндиев М.М. Начало краткой истории демократии в России [Электронный ресурс] // Пишем историю сами: портал. URL: https://memory.history90.ru/show/36 (дата обращения: 16.05.2022).
Assmann J. Communicative and Cultural Memory // Cultural Memory Studies: An International and Interdisciplinary Handbook / ed. by A. Erll, A. Nünning. Berlin; New York: Walter de Gruyter, 2008. Р. 109−118.
Bell J.A. Museums as Relational Entities: The Politics and Poetics of Heritage // Reviews in Anthropology. 2012. Vol. 41, no. 1. P. 70–92.
Boele O. “Perestroika and the 1990s − Those Were the Best Years of My Life!” Nostalgia for the Post-Soviet Limbo // Post-Soviet Nostalgia Confronting the Empire’s Legacies / eds. by O. Boele, B. Noordenbos, K. Robbe. Routledge, 2019. P. 203−223.
Gorbachev O. The Namedni Project and the Evolution of Nostalgia in Post-Soviet Russia // Canadian Slavonic Papers/Revue canadienne des slavistes. 2015. Vol. 57, no. 3-4. P. 180–194.
Irwin-Zarecka I. Frames of Remembrance. The Dynamics of Collective Memory. New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers, 1994. 214 p.
Janack J.A. The Future’s Foundation in a Contested Past: Nostalgia and Dystalgia in the 1996 Russian Presidential Campaign // Southern Communication Journal. 1999. Vol. 65, no. 1. P. 34−48.
Khazanov A.M. Selecting the Past: the Politics of Memory in Moscow's History Museums // City & Society. 2000. Vol. 12, no. 2. P. 35−62.
Makhortykh М. #givemebackmy90s: Memories of the First Post-Soviet Decade in Russia on Instagram and TikTok // Cultures on History Forum. 28 Jun 2021. URL: https://www.cultures-of-history.uni-jena.de/exhibitions/givemebackmy90s-memories-of-the-first-post-soviet-decade (accessed: 19.05.2022).
Malinova O. Framing the Collective Memory of the 1990s as a Legitimation Tool for Putin’s Regime // Problems of Post-Communism. 2021. Vol. 68. no. 5. P. 429−441.
Nora P. General Introduction: Between Memory and History // Realms of Memory. Rethinking the French Past. Vol. 1. Conflicts and Divisions / Under the Direction of Pierre Nora; Transl. by Arthur Goldhammer. New York: Columbia University Press, 1996. P. 1−23.
Norris S.M. From Communist Museums to Museums of Communism. An Introduction // Museums of Communism / ed. by S.M. Norris. Bloomington: Indiana University Press. 2020. P. 1−16.
Olick J. Collective Memory: Two Cultures // Sociological Theory. 1999. Vol. 17, no. 3. P. 333−348.
Schimpfössl E., Yablokov I. Power Lost and Freedom Relinquished: Russian Journalists Assessing the First Post-Soviet Decade // The Russian Review. 2017. Vol. 76, no. 3. P. 526–541.
Sharafutdinova G. The Red Mirror: Putin's Leadership and Russia's Insecure Identity. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2020. 237 p.
Sharafutdinova G. Public Opinion Formation and Group Identity: The Politics of National Identity Salience in Post-Crimea Russia // Problems of Post-Communism. 2020. 02 November.
Smith K.E. Mythmaking in the New Russia: Politics and Memory during the Yeltsin Era. Ithaca etc.: Cornell University Press, 2002. 223 p.
Wertsch J.V. Voices of Collective Remembering. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2002. 202 p.
References
Abramov, R. & A.A. Chistiakova (2012), “The nostalgic representations of the late Soviet period in media projects of L. Parfenov”, Mezhdunarodnyy zhurnal issledivaniy kultury, vol. 6, № 1, pp. 52–58.
Anikin, D.A. (2021), “The point of (non)return: the collapse of the USSR and formation of new Russia in the memorial discourse of ROC”, Tempus et Memoria, vol. 2, № 3, pp. 27–35.
Assman, A. (2014), Dlinnaya ten’ proshlogo: Memorial’naya kul’tura i istoricheskaya politika [The long sha-dow of the past: Memorial culture and historical politics], Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, Moscow, Russia, 328 p.
Assmann, J. (2008), “Communicative and Cultural Memory”, in Erll, A. & A. Nünning (eds.), Cultural Memory Studies: An International and Interdisciplinary Handbook, Walter de Gruyter, Berlin, Germany; New York, USA, pp. 109–118.
Bell, J.A. (2012) “Museums as Relational Entities: The Politics and Poetics of Heritage”, Reviews in Anthropol-ogy, vol. 41, no.1, pp. 70–92.
Boele, O. (2019) “«Perestroika and the 1990s – Those Were the Best Years of My Life!» Nostalgia for the Post-Soviet Limbo”, in Boele, O., Noordenbos, B. & K. Robbe (eds.), Post-Soviet Nostalgia Confronting the Empire’s Legacies, Routledge, London, UK, pp. 203–223.
Bolotnikov, V. (n.d.), “My 1990s”, website Pishem istoriyu sami [We’re writing history by ourselves], available at: https://memory.history90.ru/show/117 (accessed 16.05.2022).
Bonch-Osmolovskaya, A. (2018), “The Names of Time: Epithets of Decades in the National Corpus of Russian language as Projection of Cultural Memory”, Shagi – Steps, vol. 4, № 3–4, pp. 115–146.
Chernova, I.A. (n.d.), “My 1990s. Part 1. The time of hope, interesting work and real changes”, website Pishem istoriyu sami [We’re writing history by ourselves], available at: https://memory.history90.ru/show/400 (accessed 16.05.2022).
Engström, M. (2021), “Recycling of the Post-Soviet Counterculture, and the New Aesthetics of the “Second World”, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, № 3, pp. 70–88.
Gorbachev, O. (2015), “The Namedni project and the evolution of nostalgia in post-Soviet Russia”, Canadian Slavonic Papers/Revue canadienne des slavistes, vol. 57, № 3–4, pp. 180–194.
Greben’, О. & K. Agepeeva (2020), “Perceptions of the 1990s”, Levada Center, 6.04.2020, available at: https://www.levada.ru/2020/04/06/vospriyatie-devyanostyh/ (accessed 16.05.2022).
Irwin-Zarecka, I. (1994), Frames of Remembrance. The Dynamics of Collective Memory, Transaction Publishers, New Brunswick etc., Russia, xiv, 214 p.
Janack, J.A. (1999), “The future’s foundation in a contested past: Nostalgia and Dystalgia in the 1996 Russian Presidential Campaign”, Southern Communication Journal, vol. 65, № 1, pp. 34–48.
Khazanov, A.M. (2000) “Selecting the Past: the politics of memory in Moscow's history museums”, City & So-ciety, vol. 12, № 2, pp. 35–62.
Kogan, D.L. (n.d.), “The best years of Russian history”, website Pishem istoriyu sami [We’re writing history by ourselves], available at: https://memory.history90.ru/show/349 (accessed 16.05.2022).
Latov, Yu.V. (2018), “Paradoxes of memory of the recent past: USSR under Brezhnev, Russia under Yeltsin and Putin in perception of the current generation of Russians”, Polis. Potiticheskie issledovaniya, № 5, pp. 116–133.
Lesnevskaya, O.V. (n.d.), “Proschay, XX vek! Chapter 16”, website Pishem istoriyu sami [We’re writing history by ourselves], available at: https://memory.history90.ru/show/374 (accessed 16.05.2022).
Lesnevskaya, O.V. (n.d.), “Proschay, XX vek! Chapter 8”, website Pishem istoriyu sami [We’re writing history by ourselves], available at: https://memory.history90.ru/show/366 (accessed 16.05.2022).
Makhortykh, М. (2021), “#givemebackmy90s: memories of the first post-Soviet decade in Russia on Instagram and TikTok”, Cultures on History Forum, 28 Jun 2021, available at: https://www.cultures-of-history.uni-jena.de/exhibitions/givemebackmy90s-memories-of-the-first-post-soviet-decade (assessed 19.05.2022).
Malinova, O. (2021), “Framing the Collective Memory of the 1990s as a Legitimation Tool for Putin’s Regime”, Problems of Post-Communism, Vol. 68, № 5, pp. 429–441.
Malinova, O.Yu. (2016), “The official historical narrative as a part of identity policy of the Russian state: from the 1990s to the 2000s”, Polis. Potiticheskie issledovaniya, № 6, pp. 139–158.
Malinova, O.Yu. (2018), “Justifying the political course of the 2000s and constructing the myth about “the hard nineties” in Vladimir Putin’s discourse”, Politicheskaya nauka, № 3, pp. 45–69.
Malinova, O.Yu. (2019), “Framing memory about the reforms of the 1990s in the liberal discourse in the 2000s”, Yuzhno-rossiyskiy zhurnal sotsialnykh nauk, № 3, pp. 91–105.
Malinova, O.Yu. (2020), “The issue of “the hard 1990s” in discourses of Russian communists and national-patriots”, Vestnik Permskogo universiteta. Politologiya, vol. 14, № 2, pp. 53–63.
Marinina, A. (ed.) (2017), Byli 90-kh [The real stories of the 1990s], Vol. 1. Kakh my vyzhivali [How we sur-vived], Eksmo Press, Moscow, Russia, 352 p.
Marinina, A. (ed.) (2018), Byli 90-kh [The real stories of the 1990s], Vol. 2. Epokha likhoi sviatosti [The epoch of dash sainthood], Eksmo Press, Moscow, Russia, 384 p.
Merzlyakova, V.N. (2019), “Mediatization of the collective memory of the 1990s in RuNet”, Vestnik RGGU. Seriia “Literaturovedenie. Yazykoznanie. Kul’turologiya”, № 8, pp. 289–302.
Miller, A.I. & O.Yu. Malinova (2021), “After a conference about memory of the 1990s: a dialogue”, Tempus et Memoria, № 3, pp. 6–12.
Mishina, Е.А. (n.d.), “Coup d’état”, website Pishem istoriyu sami [We’re writing history by ourselves], available at: https://memory.history90.ru/show/47 (accessed 16.05.2022).
“Nikita Mikhalkov protiv “Yeltsin Tsentra”: kak razvivalsya conflict” (2016), website of TASS, 12.12.2016, available at: https://tass.ru/obschestvo/3863882 (accessed 16.05.2022).
Nora, P. (1996), “General Introduction: Between Memory and History”, in Pierre, N. (ed.), Realms of Memory. Rethinking the French Past. Vol. 1. Conflicts and Divisions, Columbia University Press, New York, USA, pp. 1–23.
Norris, S.M. (2020), “From Communist Museums to Museums of Communism. An Introduction”, in Norris, S.M. (ed.), Museums of Communism, Indiana University Press, Bloomington, USA, pp. 1–16.
Olick, J. (1999), “Collective Memory: Two Cultures”, Sociological Theory, vol. 17, № 3, pp. 333–348.
Schimpfössl, E. & I. Yablokov (2017), “Power Lost and Freedom Relinquished: Russian Journalists Assessing the First Post-Soviet Decade”, The Russian Review, vol. 76, № 3, pp. 526–541.
Sharafutdinova, G. (2020a), The Red Mirror: Putin's Leadership and Russia's Insecure Identity, Oxford Univer-sity Press, Oxford, UK, xv, 237 p.
Sharafutdinova, G. (2020b), “Public opinion formation and group identity: the politics of national identity sa-lience in post-Crimea Russia”, Problems of Post-Communism, published online: 02 Nov 2020, DOI: 10.1080/10758216.2020.1829975.
Sinelnikova, E.S. & E.V. Zinovyeva (2018), “Historical memory of the 1990s in Russia”, Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta. Seriya 14. Psikhologiya, № 4, pp. 74–88.
Smith, K.E. (2002), Mythmaking in the New Russia: Politics and Memory during the Yeltsin Era, Cornell Uni-versity Press, Ithaca etc., USA, xi, 223 p.
Sorokin, A.I. (n.d.), “From the diary of an employee of the Bolshoi Theatre: Moscow in 1990–1993”, website Pishem istoriyu sami [We’re writing history by ourselves], available at: https://memory.history90.ru/show/2 (ac-cessed 16.05.2022).
Suslov, A.B. & E.V. Shuyskaya (2020), “Democratic transition in Russia in the 1990s in textbooks on Russian history”, Izvestiya AltGU. Istoricheskie nauki i archeologiya, № 6 (116), pp. 68–72.
Utekhin, I. V. (2021), “The visual images of the 1990s in Instagram: a commercialization of nostalgia”, Tempus et Memoria, 2, № 3, pp. 60–72.
Vlasov, Yu.B. (n.d.), “Russia in the 1990s: The Young reformers about the first experience of democratic re-forms”, website Pishem istoriyu sami [We’re writing history by ourselves], available at: https://memory.history90.ru/show/10 (accessed 16.05.2022).
Wertsch, J.V. (2002), Voices of Collective Remembering, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, 202 p.
Yandiev, М.М. (n.d.), “The beginning of short history of democracy in Russia”, website Pishem istoriyu sami [We’re writing history by ourselves], available at: https://memory.history90.ru/show/36 (accessed 16.05.2022).
