SEXUAL FREEDOM AND PROTECTION OF WOMEN: CHALLENGES OF CODIFICATION IN EARLY SOVIET CRIMINAL LAW
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17072/2219-3111-2025-4-70-84Keywords:
soviet law, RSFSR, codification, revolution, gender, sexual freedom, penal code, women’s history, sexual crimesAbstract
The article examines the process of early Soviet criminal codification of the section on sexual offenses, in the creation of which Bolshevik jurists sought to establish equality between men and women. The study consistently demonstrates the stages of the development of the 1922 Code, starting with the first decrees and ending with the 1926 edition of the Criminal Code. A detailed analysis of this process proves that the creation of the Code was not unilinear – the legislators did not initially seek to establish the concept of sexual freedoms and the gender neutrality of the articles. This criminal canon was born only in the process of repeated discussions at different levels – from democratically organized legal congresses to sessions of the SNK. The study also argues that despite all the progressive aspirations of the legislators, the Code retained a paternalistic approach to the protection of women, treating them as a special category in need of state care. The authors of the draft continued to present rape as a turning point in a woman's fate and included a separate article in the code that criminalized the coercion of solely women into sexual intercourse by persons on whom they depended financially or in service. At the same time, the protection of women was still motivated by ideas of sexual freedom rather than the traditional religious or marriage norms characteristic of pre-revolutionary criminal law. Because of their novelty, these norms in the area of sexual offenses were insufficiently developed in terms of legal technique, but they contributed to a change in evidentiary procedures and certainly increased access to justice for a wide range of people, regardless of their gender or marital status.References
Герцензон А.А., Грингауз Ш.С., Дурманов Н.Д. История советского уголовного права: ис-тория советского государства и права. 1917‒1947. М.: Юрид. изд-во, 1948. 465 с.
Дурманов Н.Д. Первый советский уголовный кодекс // Советское государство и право. 1947. № 9. С. 29‒41.
Здравомыслова О.М. Как рождался «советский патриархат». Григорий Баткис о сексуаль-ной революции в России // Демографическое обозрение. 2017. № 4(1). С. 124‒143. EDN: ZGFNKZ.
Звонарев А.В. Влияние российского законодательства на развитие уголовного права Лат-вийской Республики в 1918 ‒ начале 1920-х годов // Право и права человека в современ-ном мире: тенденции, риски, перспективы развития: материалы Всерос. науч. конф., по-свящ. памяти профессора Ф.М. Рудинского, Москва, 23 апреля 2020 г. М.: Саратовский источник, 2020. С. 104‒108. EDN: EROJJC.
Марков А.Р. Что значит быть студентом: работы 1995‒2002 гг. М.: Нов. лит. обозрение, 2005. 255 с. ISBN: 5-86793-369-5. EDN: QUCAWT.
Полный курс уголовного права: в 5 т. / под ред. А.И. Коробеева. Т. II. Преступления про-тив личности. СПб.: Юрид. центр Пресс, 2008. 682 с.
Соломон П. Советская юстиция при Сталине. М.: РОССПЭН, 2008. 464 с.
Стетюха М.П. К вопросу о развитии понятия половых преступлений в отечественной уголовно-правовой науке 20-х – конца 80-х гг. XX в. // Вестник юрид. факультета Юж. фе-дер. ун-та. 2016. № 3 (2-3). С. 76–86. EDN: XCBXVJ.
Тепляков А.Г. «Сотни девушек стали женщинами...»: массовое сексуальное насилие со стороны партизан Сибири и Дальнего Востока (1918‒1920 гг.) // Государство, общество, Церковь в истории России ХХ‒XXI веков: материалы XVI Междунар. науч. конф., Ивано-во, 5–6 апреля 2017 г.: в 2 ч. Иваново: Изд-во Иванов. гос. ун-та, 2017. Ч. 2. С. 448‒452. EDN: ZQZRQF.
Хили Д. Гомосексуальное влечение в революционной России: регулирование сексуально-гендерного диссидентства / подгот. Л.В. Бессмертных. М.: Ладомир, 2008. 714 с. ISBN: 978-5-86218-470-9. EDN: QOIDAD.
Швеков Г.В. Первый советский уголовный кодекс: учеб. пособие М.: Высшая школа, 1970.
Энгельштейн Л. Ключи счастья: секс и поиски путей обновления России на рубеже XIX‒XX вв. М.: Терра, 1996. 571 с.
Borisova T., Burbank J. Russia’s Legal Trajectories // Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eura-sian History. 2018. No. 3. P. 469–508. DOI: 10.1353/kri.2018.0027. EDN: YBYITR.
Juviler P. Women and Sex in Soviet Law // Women in Russia / ed. by D. Atkinson, A. Dallin, G.W. Lapidus. Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press, 1977. 410 p.
Muravyeva M. Between Law and Morality: Violence Against Women in Nineteenth-century Russia // Women in Nineteenth-century Russia: Lives and Culture. 2011. P. 227‒238.
Muravyeva M. Legal Definitions of Sex Crimes in the Laws and Commentaries of Russian Law-yers (1860s‒1910s) // Women’s History in Russia: (Re)establishing the Field. 2014. P. 28‒49.
Naiman E. The Case of Chubarov Alley: Collective Rape, Utopian Desire and the Mentality of NEP // Russian History. 1990. No. 17(1). P. 3‒30.
Oberländer A. Shame and Modern Subjectivities. The Rape of Elizaveta Cheremnova // Inter-preting Emotions in Russia and Eastern Europe. Northern Illinois University Press, 2011. P. 82‒101.
Rendle M. The State Versus the People: Revolutionary Justice in Russia's Civil War, 1917‒1922. New York: Oxford University Press, 2020. 317 p.
Solomon P.H. Criminalization and Decriminalization in Soviet Criminal Policy, 1917‒1941 // Law & Society Review. 1982. No. 1. P. 9‒43.
References
Borisova, T., & Burbank, J. (2018). Russia’s legal trajectories. Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History, 19(3), 469–508.
Durmanov, N. D. (1947). The first Soviet penal code. Sovetskoye gosudarstvo i pravo, 9, 29–41.
Engel'shtein, L. (1996). Klyuchi schast'ya: Seks i poiski putey obnovleniya Rossii na rubezhe XIX-XX vv. [Keys of happiness: Sex and the search for modernity in fin-de-siècle Russia]. Terra.
Gertsenzon, A. A. (1948). Istoriya sovetskogo ugolovnogo prava [History of Soviet penal law]. Yuridicheskoye izdatel'stvo.
Gracheva, Yu. V., Malikov, S. V., & Chuchaev, A. I. (2015). Sovetskoye ugolovnoye ulozheniye [Soviet penal code]. Prospekt.
Granik, L. (2017). The trials of the proletarka: Sexual harassment claims in the 1920s. In P. H. Solomon, Jr. (Ed.), Reforming justice in Russia, 1864-1994 (pp. 131–167). Routledge.
Healey, D. (2009). Bolshevik sexual forensics. Cornell University Press.
Juviler, P. (1977). Women and sex in Soviet law. In D. Atkinson, A. Dallin, & G. W. Lapidus (Eds.), Women in Russia (pp. 243–265). Stanford University Press.
Khili, D. (2008). Gomoseksual'noye vlecheniye v revolyutsionnoy Rossii: regulirovaniye seksual'no-gendernogo dissidentstva [Homosexual attraction in revolutionary Russia: Regulating sexual-gender dissidence]. Ladomir.
Markov, A. R. (2005). Chto znachit byt' studentom? [What does it mean to be a student?]. Novoye Litera-turnoye Obozreniye.
Muravyeva, M. (2011). Between law and morality: Violence against women in nineteenth-century Russia. In W. Rosslyn & A. Tosi (Eds.), Women in nineteenth-century Russia: Lives and culture (pp. 227–238). Open Book Publishers.
Muravyeva, M. G. (2014). Legal definitions of sex crimes in the laws and commentaries of Russian lawyers (1860s-1910s). In M. Ilic (Ed.), Women’s history in Russia: (Re)establishing the field (pp. 28–49). Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
Naiman, E. (1990). The case of Chubarov Alley: Collective rape, utopian desire and the mentality of NEP. Rus-sian History, 17(1), 3–30.
Oberländer, A. (2011). Shame and modern subjectivities: The rape of Elizaveta Cheremnova. In M. Steinberg & V. Sobol (Eds.), Interpreting emotions in Russia and Eastern Europe (pp. 82–101). University of Pittsburgh Press.
Korobeev, A. I. (Ed.). (2008). Polnyy kurs ugolovnogo prava: V 5 t. T. 2: Prestupleniya protiv lichnosti [Com-plete course of criminal law: In 5 vols. Vol. 2: Crimes against the person]. Yuridicheskiy tsentr Press.
Rendle, M. (2020). The state versus the people: Revolutionary justice in Russia's Civil War, 1917-1922. Oxford University Press.
Shvekov, G. V. (1970). Pervyy sovetskiy ugolovnyy kodeks [The first Soviet penal code]. Vysshaya shkola.
Solomon, P. H., Jr. (2008). Sovetskaya yustitsiya pri Staline [Soviet criminal justice under Stalin]. ROSSPEN.
Solomon, P. H., Jr. (1982). Criminalization and decriminalization in Soviet criminal policy, 1917-1941. Law & Society Review, 16(1), 9–43.
Stetiukha, M. P. (2016). On the development of the concept of sexual crimes in Russian criminal law science from the 1920s to the late 1980s. Vestnik Yuridicheskogo Fakul'teta Yuzhnogo Federal'nogo Universiteta, 3(2-3), 76–86.
Tepliakov, A. G. (2017). "Hundreds of girls became women...": Mass sexual violence by partisans of Siberia and the Far East (1918-1920). In Gosudarstvo, obshchestvo, Tserkov' v istorii Rossii XX-XXI vekov: Materialy XVI Mezhdunarodnoy nauchnoy konferentsii: v 2 chastyakh. Chast' 2 [State, Society, and the Church in the History of Russia in the 20th-21st Centuries: Proceedings of the 16th International Scientific Conference: in 2 parts. Part 2] (pp. 448–452). Ivanovskiy gosudarstvennyy universitet.
Zdravomyslova, O. M. (2017). How the "Soviet patriarchate" was born: Grigoriy Batkis on the sexual revolution in Russia. Demograficheskoye obozreniye, 4(1), 124–143.
Zvonarev, A. V. (2020). Influence of Russian legislation on the development of criminal law of the Republic of Latvia in 1918-early 1920s. In Pravo i prava cheloveka v sovremennom mire: tendentsii, riski, perspektivy razvitiya: materialy Vserossiyskoy nauchnoy konferentsii, posvyashchennoy pamyati professora F.M. Rudinskogo (g. Moskva, 23 aprelya 2020 g.) [Law and human rights in the modern world: trends, risks, devel-opment prospects: Proceedings of the All-Russian scientific conference dedicated to the memory of Professor F.M. Rudinsky (Moscow, April 23, 2020).] (pp. 104–108). Saratovskiy istochnik.
