METHODS AND RESULTS OF ESTIMATING OF EDUCATION EXPENDITURES IN RUSSIA (LATE 19TH – EARLY 20TH CENTURIES)
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17072/2219-3111-2025-2-115-129Keywords:
cliometrics, long historical data series, modernization, human capital, public finance, institutional sectors of the economyAbstract
This paper focuses on the reconstruction of the value-based measures of the education sector as a branch of the national economy of the late Russian Empire. The purpose of the study is to improve existing estimates and assessments of the role of education and human capital at the historical stage of the country’s development. It was the period when Russia underwent a transition from the Malthusian to the “modern” regime of economic growth by modernizing its economic and social structure. The research addresses the following tasks: 1) presentation of the source data collected in electronic format (reports of the Office of the State Control, the Ministry of Public Education, and the Central Statistical Committee); 2) reconstruction of expenditure series on education at different levels and from various institutional sources; 3) pioneering estimation of the human capital stock based on its replacement cost and income-based value; 4) direct comparison of the resulting measures expressed in monetary units with other key macroeconomic indicators of the country. Estimates of the respective measures of Russia’s education system and the human capital formed through it are available in economic history literature for the period from the 1920s to the 2000s; this study extends them back in time and makes them generally comparable over time. To ensure such comparability, the author employs methods developed in economic history literature, which address the insufficiency of historical quantitative evidence and are appropriate for cross-country comparisons. There is some room for upward adjustment of the cost-based estimates as the sources underreport the size of non-government funds; however, their share diminished over time. The research findings indicate that during the launch of the “modern” economic growth regime, the rate of human capital accumulation in Russia was on the rise, and its cost-based measure increased faster than that of physical capital. A question arises whether this accumulation could have been even more rapid relative to the competitive geopolitical environment and the higher base achieved by Japan. The author outlines prospects for employing the findings in further empirical and theoretical studies of Russia’s and comparative long-run growth and development.References
Беккер Г.С. Человеческое поведение: экономический подход. Избранные труды по экономиче-ской теории. М.: ГУ ВШЭ, 2003 [1957–1993]. 670 с.
Грегори П. Экономический рост Российской империи (конец XIX в. ‒ начало XX в.): новые подсчеты и оценки. М.: Российская политическая энциклопедия (РОССПЭН), 2003 [1982]. 255 с. ISBN: 5-8243-0291-X. EDN: QQBOTD.
Диденко Д.В. Динамика и институциональные источники накопления человеческого капитала в регионах России (вторая половина XIX в. – начало XX в.) // Экономическая история: ежегодник. М.: Институт российской истории РАН, 2021. С. 107‒149. EDN: NFHGPT.
Диденко Д.В. Интеллектуалоемкая экономика: человеческий капитал в российском и мировом социально-экономическом развитии. СПб.: Алетейя, 2015. 408 с. ISBN: 978-5-906792-63-1. EDN: ZSZPKB.
Диденко Д.В. Формирование человеческого капитала в условиях фронтирных модернизаций в поздней Российской империи // Уральский исторический вестник. 2024. № 1 (82). С. 99−107. DOI: 10.30759/1728-9718-2024-1(82)-99-107. EDN: FYRPHJ.
Кендрик Дж. Совокупный капитал США и его формирование. М.: Прогресс, 1978 [1976]. 275 с.
Куломзин А.Н. Опытный подсчет современного состояния нашего образования. СПб.: Государ-ственная типография, 1912. 49 с.
Мельянцев В.А. Генезис современного (интенсивного) экономического роста и проблемы догоняющего и перегоняющего развития в странах Запада, Востока и России. М.: Гуманитарий, 2004. 53 с.
Миронов Б.Н. Грамотность в России 1797–1917 годов // История СССР. 1985. № 4. С. 137–153. EDN: WBTSDL.
Миронов Б.Н. Российская империя: от традиции к модерну: в 3 т. 2-е изд. СПб.: Дмитрий Була-нин, 2018.
Миронов Б.Н. Экономический рост и образование в России и СССР в XIX–XX веках // Отече-ственная история. 1994. № 4-5. С. 111–125. EDN: RSNPXX.
Нефедов С.А. История России. Факторный анализ. М.: Территория будущего, 2011. Т. II. 688 с. ISBN: 978-5-91129-069-6. EDN: PVEDYR.
Ростоу В.В. Стадии экономического роста. Нью-Йорк: Фредерик А. Прегер, 1961. 236 с.
Струмилин С.Г. Хозяйственное значение народного образования // Проблемы экономики труда. М.: Наука, 1982 [1924]. С. 99‒125.
Хрулев С.С. Финансы России в связи с экономическим положением ее населения. 2-е изд. СПб.: Акц. общ. Брокгауз-Ефрон, 1909. 296 с.
Янжул И.И., Чупров А.И., Янжул Е.Н. Экономическая оценка народного образования. СПб.: И.Н. Скороходов, 1896. 87 с.
Broadberry S., Korchmina E. Catching-up and Falling Behind: Russian Economic Growth, 1690s‒1880s // Journal of Economic History. 2024. Vol. 84, no. 4. P. 997‒1028. DOI: 10.1017/
s0022050724000287.
Cheremukhin A., Golosov M., Guriev S., Tsyvinski A. The Industrialization and Economic Development of Russia through the Lens of a Neoclassical Growth Model // The Review of Economic Studies. 2017. Vol. 84, no. 2. P. 613–649. DOI: 10.1093/restud/rdw026.
Didenko D., Földvári P., Van Leeuwen B. The Spread of Human Capital in the Former Soviet Union Area in a Comparative Perspective: Exploring a New Dataset // Journal of Eurasian Studies. 2013. Vol. 4, no. 2. P. 123–135. Available at: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/
S1879366513000122 (accessed: 01.03.2024). DOI: 10.1016/j.euras.2013.03.002. EDN: RFHDWF.
Földvári P., Van Leeuwen B. An Estimation of the Human Capital Stock in Eastern and Central Europe // Eastern European Economics. 2005. Vol. 43, no. 6. P. 53‒65. DOI: 10.2753/EEE0012-8755430603.
Galor O. Unified Growth Theory. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press, 2011. 328 р. DOI: 10.1515/9781400838868.
Godo Y., Hayami Y. Catching-Up in Education in the Economic Catch-Up of Japan with the United States, 1890–1990 // Economic Development and Cultural Change. 2002. Vol. 50, no. 4. P. 961–978. DOI: 10.1086/342762. EDN: DUUHVL.
Goldin С. Human Capital // Handbook of Cliometrics / eds. by C. Diebolt, M. Haupert. Berlin – Heidelberg: Springer-Verlag, 2016. P. 55‒86. DOI: 10.1007/978-3-642-40406-1_23.
Johnson W.H.E. Russia’s Educational Heritage. 2nd ed. New York: Octagon Books, 1969. 360 р.
Judson R. Measuring Human Capital Like Physical Capital: What Does It Tell Us? // Bulletin of Eco-nomic Research. 2002. Vol. 54. P. 209‒231. DOI: 10.1111/1467-8586.00150. EDN: DZCBQZ.
Kaser M. Education in Tsarist and Soviet Development // Essays in Honour of E.H. Carr / ed. by C. Abramsky. Macmillan – London, 1974. P. 229–254. DOI: 10.1007/978-1-349-01725-6_11.
Kaser M.C. Education and Economic Progress: Experience in Industrialized Market Economies // The Economics of Education / ed. by E.A.G. Robinson and J.E. Vaizey. London: Macmillan – New York: St Martin's Press, 1966. P. 142‒173. DOI: 10.1007/978-1-349-08464-7_4.
Kokkinen A. On Finland’s Economic Growth and Convergence with Sweden and the EU15 in the 20th Century. Research Report 258. Helsinki: Statistics Finland, 2012. Available at: https://www.stat.fi/tup/julkaisut/tiedostot/978-952-244-334-2.pdf (accessed: 01.03.2024).
Kuznets S. Modern Economic Growth: Rate, Structure, and Spread. New Haven – London, 1966. 529 р.
Levine S., Kawada H. Human Resources and Japanese Industrial Development. Princeton (N.J.): Princeton University Press, 1980. 332 р. DOI: 10.1515/9781400855827.
Mankiw N.G., Romer D., Weil D.N. A Contribution to the Empirics of Economic Growth // Quarterly Journal of Economics. 1992. Vol. 107, no. 2. P. 407‒437. DOI: 10.2307/2118477. EDN: HKGMQD.
Mincer J. Schooling, Experience and Earnings. New York: National Bureau of Economic Research, 1974. 152 p.
Schultz T.W. The Economic Value of Education. London – New York: Columbia University Press, 1963. 92 р.
Tabata S., Tabata T. State Budget // Russian Economic Development over Three Centuries: New Data and Inferences / eds. by M. Kuboniwa [et al.]. Singapore: Palgrave Macmillan, 2019. P. 251‒289. DOI: 10.1007/978-981-13-8429-5_8.
Van Leeuwen B. Human Capital and Economic Growth in India, Indonesia, and Japan: A Quantitative Analysis, 1890‒2000. PhD Thesis. Utrecht University: Box Press Publishers, 2007. Available at: http://www.basvanleeuwen.net/bestanden/proefschrift/proefschriftbvl.pdf (accessed: 01.03.2024).
Van Leeuwen B., Didenko D., Földvári P. Inspiration Versus Perspiration in Economic Development of the Former Soviet Union and China (ca. 1920–2010) // Economics of Transition. 2015. Vol. 23, no. 1. P. 213–246. DOI: 10.1111/ecot.12060. EDN: ZWHVGN.
Van Leeuwen B., Földvári P. Capital Accumulation and Growth in Central Europe, 1920‒2006 // Eastern European Economics. 2013. Vol. 51, no. 5. P. 69‒93.
Van Leeuwen B., Földvári P. Capital Accumulation and Growth in Hungary, 1924‒2006 // Acta Oeco-nomica. 2011. Vol. 61, no. 2. P. 143‒164.
Van Leeuwen B., Földvári P. How Much Human Capital Does Eastern Europe Have? Measurement Methods and Results // Post-Communist Economies. 2008а. Vol. 20, no. 2. P. 189‒201.
Van Leeuwen B., Földvári P. Human Capital and Economic Growth in Asia 1890‒2000: a Time-Series Analysis // Asian Economic Journal. 2008b. Vol. 22, no. 3. P. 225‒240.
Van Leeuwen B., Van Leeuwen-Li J., Földvári P. Human Capital in Republican and New China: Re-gional and Long-Term Trends // Economic History of Developing Regions. 2017. Vol. 32, no. 1. P. 1‒36.
References
Becker, G. S. (2003). Chelovecheskoe povedenie: ekonomicheskiy podkhod. Izbrannye trudy po ekonomicheskoy teorii [Human behavior: An economic approach. Selected works on economic theory]. GU VShE. (Original works published 1957–1993)
Broadberry, S., & Korchmina, E. (2024). Catching-up and falling behind: Russian economic growth, 1690s-1880s. Journal of Economic History, 84(4), 997–1028. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022050724000287
Cheremukhin, A., Golosov, M., Guriev, S., & Tsyvinski, A. (2017). The industrialization and economic development of Russia through the lens of a neoclassical growth model. The Review of Economic Studies, 84(2), 613–649. https://doi.org/10.1093/restud/rdw026
Didenko, D. V. (2015). Intellektualoemkaya ekonomika: Chelovecheskiy kapital v rossiyskom i mirovom sotsial'no-ekonomicheskom razvitii [Knowledge-intensive economy: Human capital in Russian and global socio-economic development]. Aletheia.
Didenko, D. V. (2021). Dynamics and institutional sources of human capital accumulation in Russia's regions (19th – early 20th centuries). In L. I. Borodkin et al. (Eds.), Ekonomicheskaya istoriya: Ezhegodnik. 2020 (pp. 107-149). Institut Rossiyskoy Istorii RAN.
Didenko, D. V. (2024). Human capital formation in the processes of frontier modernizations in the late Russian Empire. Ural Historical Journal, 1(82), 99–107.
Didenko, D., Földvári, P., & Van Leeuwen, B. (2013). The spread of human capital in the former Soviet Union area in a comparative perspective: Exploring a new dataset. Journal of Eurasian Studies, 4(2), 123–135. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1879366513000122
Földvári, P., & Van Leeuwen, B. (2005). An estimation of the human capital stock in Eastern and Central Europe. Eastern European Economics, 43(6), 53–65.
Galor, O. (2011). Unified growth theory. Princeton University Press.
Godo, Y., & Hayami, Y. (2002). Catching-up in education in the economic catch-up of Japan with the United States, 1890–1990. Economic Development and Cultural Change, 50(4), 961–978.
Goldin, C. (2016). Human capital. In C. Diebolt & M. Haupert (Eds.), Handbook of cliometrics (pp. 55-86). Springer.
Gregory, P. (2003). Ekonomicheskiy rost Rossiyskoy imperii (konets XIX v. – nachalo XX v.): Novye podschety i otsenki [The economic growth of the Russian Empire (late 19th century – early 20th century): New calculations and estimates]. ROSSPEN. (Original work published 1982)
Johnson, W. H. E. (1969). Russia's educational heritage. Octagon Books.
Judson, R. (2002). Measuring human capital like physical capital: What does it tell us? Bulletin of Economic Research, 54(3), 209–231.
Kaser, M. (1974). Education in Tsarist and Soviet development. In C. Abramsky (Ed.), Essays in honour of E.H. Carr (pp. 229–254). Macmillan.
Kaser, M. C. (1966). Education and economic progress: Experience in industrialized market economies. In E. A. G. Robinson & J. E. Vaizey (Eds.), The economics of education (pp. 142-173). Macmillan.
Kendrick, J. (1978). Sovokupnyy kapital SShA i ego formirovanie [The formation and stocks of total capital]. Progress. (Original work published 1976)
Khrulev, S. S. (1909). Finansy Rossii v svyazi s ekonomicheskim polozheniem ee naseleniya [Russia's finances in relationship with economic conditions of its population]. Brokgauz-Efron.
Kokkinen, A. (2012). On Finland's economic growth and convergence with Sweden and the EU15 in the 20th century (Research Report No. 258). Statistics Finland. https://www.stat.fi/tup/julkaisut/tiedostot/978-952-244-334-2.pdf
Kulomzin, A. N. (1912). Opytnyy podschet sovremennogo sostoyaniya nashego obrazovaniya [An estimation of the current state of our education]. State Printing House.
Kuznets, S. (1966). Modern economic growth: Rate, structure, and spread. Yale University Press.
Levine, S., & Kawada, H. (1980). Human resources and Japanese industrial development. Princeton University Press.
Mankiw, N. G., Romer, D., & Weil, D. N. (1992). A contribution to the empirics of economic growth. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 107(2), 407–437.
Melyantsev, V. A. (2004). Genezis sovremennogo (intensivnogo) ekonomicheskogo rosta i problemy dogonyayushchego i peregonyayushchego razvitiya v stranakh Zapada, Vostoka i Rossii [The genesis of modern (intensive) economic growth and the problems of catching up and surpassing development in the countries of the West, East and Russia]. Gumanitarii.
Mincer, J. (1974). Schooling, experience and earnings. National Bureau of Economic Research.
Mironov, B. N. (1985). Literacy in Russia, 1797-1917. Istoriya SSSR, 4, 137–153.
Mironov, B. N. (1994). Economic growth and education in Russia and the USSR in the 19th – 20th centuries. Otechestvennaya Istoriya, 4–5, 111–125.
Mironov, B. N. (2018). Rossiyskaya imperiya: ot traditsii k modernu [The Russian Empire: From tradition to modernity] (Vols. 1–3). Dmitrii Bulanin.
Nefedov, S. A. (2011). Istoriya Rossii. Faktornyy analiz. T. II [History of Russia. Factor analysis. Vol. II]. Territoriya Budushchego.
Rostow, W. W. (1961). Stadii ekonomicheskogo rosta [Stages of economic growth]. Frederick A. Praeger.
Schultz, T. W. (1963). The economic value of education. Columbia University Press.
Strumilin, S. G. (1982). The economic significance of public education. In Problemy ekonomiki truda [Essays on labor economics] (pp. 99-125). Nauka. (Original work published 1924)
Tabata, S., & Tabata, T. (2019). State budget. In M. Kuboniwa et al. (Eds.), Russian economic development over three centuries: New data and inferences (pp. 251-289). Palgrave Macmillan.
Van Leeuwen, B. (2007). Human capital and economic growth in India, Indonesia, and Japan: A quantitative analysis, 1890-2000 [Doctoral dissertation, Utrecht University]. Box Press. http://www.basvanleeuwen.net/bestanden/proefschrift/proefschriftbvl.pdf
Van Leeuwen, B., & Földvári, P. (2008a). How much human capital does Eastern Europe have? Measurement methods and results. Post-Communist Economies, 20 (2), 189–201.
Van Leeuwen, B., & Földvári, P. (2008b). Human capital and economic growth in Asia 1890-2000: A time-series analysis. Asian Economic Journal, 22(3), 225–240.
Van Leeuwen, B., & Földvári, P. (2011). Capital accumulation and growth in Hungary, 1924-2006. Acta Oeconomica, 61(2), 143–164.
Van Leeuwen, B., & Földvári, P. (2013). Capital accumulation and growth in Central Europe, 1920-2006. Eastern European Economics, 51(5), 69–93.
Van Leeuwen, B., Didenko, D., & Földvári, P. (2015). Inspiration versus perspiration in economic develop-ment of the Former Soviet Union and China (ca. 1920–2010). Economics of Transition, 23(1), 213–246.
Van Leeuwen, B., Van Leeuwen-Li, J., & Földvári, P. (2017). Human capital in Republican and New China: Regional and long-term trends. Economic History of Developing Regions, 32(1), 1–36.
Yanzhul, I. I., Chuprov, A. I., & Yanzhul, E. N. (1896). Ekonomicheskaya otsenka narodnogo obrazovaniya [Economic evaluation of public education]. I. N. Skorokhodov.
