“NATIONAL INDIFFERENCE” OF ELITES AND THE DYNAMICS OF PERIPHERAL NATIONALISMS IN THE RUSSIAN EMPIRE IN THE EARLY 20TH CENTURY
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17072/2219-3111-2025-2-35-45Keywords:
nationalism, national indifference, the Russian Empire, the Western borderlands, elitesAbstract
The concept of “national indifference” was introduced by historians of the Habsburg Bohemia in the second half of the 19th and the beginning of the 20th century. describes the inability or unwillingness of ordinary people to support nationalist movements or exclusively identify with a promoted national community. In essence, it emerges when nationalist activism becomes widespread. This article proposes applying the concept of national indifference to the history of the western borderlands of the Russian Empire while broadening it to encompass the strategic resistance of elite groups in Bessarabia, Western Krai, lands of former Kingdom of Poland and the Baltic gubernia. Motivated by conformism, fear for their status, and a desire to avoid exacerbating ethnic conflicts in ethnically heterogeneous provinces of the Empire, these groups consciously resisted the efforts of nationalist activists for ethnic mobilization. The elites of Bessarabia and the Krajovians of the Northwestern Krai were also frightened by the threat of further marginalization in the nation-states that were to replace the empire according to the nationalists' plans. These groups consciously resisted the efforts of national activists to mobilize along ethnic lines. Applying the concept of “national indifference” gives additional opportunities to overcome the narrow perspective of national narratives.References
Драгоманов М.П. Вибране. Киев: Либідь, 1991. 688 c. DOI: 10.1136/thx.46.9.688-a.
Мартинюк О. Російський націоналізм як соціально-політичний феномен у виборчому процесі Правобережної України (1906–1912): дис. … канд. ист. наук. Kиев, 2016. 261 c.
Миллер А.И. Украинский вопрос и политика идентичности. М.: ИНИОН РАН, 2024. 524 c. ISBN: 978-5-248-01111-7. EDN: IEXKBT.
Скоропадський П. Спогади: Кінець 1917 – грудень 1918. Київ: Інститут української археографії та джерелознавства ім. М.С. Грушевського НАН Украины, 1995. 246 c.
Славянские матицы: XIX век. М.: Институт славяноведения и балканистики РАН, 1996. Ч. 1–2. 198 c.
Чикаленко Е. Щоденник. Т. 1. 1907–1917. Киев: Темпора, 2004. 424 с.
Berecz Á. Review: National Indifference and the History of Nationalism in Modern Europe // Hungar-ian Historical Review. 2019. Vol. 8, no. 3. P. 636–638.
Bjork J.E. Neither German nor Pole: Catholicism and National Indifference in a Central European Borderland. Michigan: University of Michigan Press, 2008. 304 p. DOI: 10.3998/mpub.217738.
Bolin P., Douglas Ch. National Indifference’ in the Baltic territories? A Critical Assessment // Journal of Baltic Studies. 2007. Vol. 48, no. 1. P. 13–22. DOI: 10.1080/01629778.2016.1269432.
Brüggemann K., Wezel K. Nationally Indifferent or Ardent Nationalists? On the Options for Being German in Russia’s Baltic Provinces, 1905–1917 // Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian His-tory. 2019. No. 20 (1). P. 39–62. DOI: 10.1353/kri.2019.0002.
Carrol A., Zanoun L. The View from the Border. A Comparative Study of Autonomism in Alsace and the Moselle, 1918–1929 // European Review of History. 2011.Vol. 18, no. 4. P. 465–486. DOI: 10.1080/13507486.2011.590184.
Cusco A. Russians, Romanians, or Neither? Mobilization of Ethnicity and “National Indifference” in Early 20th-Century Bessarabia // Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History. 2019.
No. 20 (1). P. 7–38. DOI: 10.1353/kri.2019.0001. EDN: VTRECL.
Hupka Ja. Z czasów wielkiej wojny. Pamiętnik nie kombatanta. Niwiska, 1936. 464 s.
Judson P.M. Guardians of the Nation. Activists on the Language Frontiers of Imperial Austria. Har-vard: Harvard University Press, 2006. 332 p. DOI: 10.2307/j.ctv22jnrgp.
Judson P. Making Minorities and Majorities: National Indifference and National Self Determination in Habsburg Central Europe // Sovereignty, Nationalism, and the Quest for Homogeneity in Interwar Eu-rope. London: Bloomsbury Academic, 2023. P. 21–38. DOI: 10.5040/9781350263413.ch-2.
King J. Budweiser into Czechs and Germans: a Local History of Bohemian Politics, 1848–1948. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2002. 304 p. DOI: 10.1515/9780691186382.
Kraevaia ideia, kanets XIX – pachatak XX stagoddzia: Antalogiia. Vilnius: Palitychnaia sfera, 2014.
Krajowość – tradycje zgody narodów w dobie nacjonalizmu: Materiały z międzynarodowej konferencji naukowej w Instytucie Historii UAM w Poznaniu (11–12 maja 1998). Poznań: Instytut Historii UAM, 1999. 158 s.
Michalczyk A. Heimat, Kirche und Nation. Deutsche und polnische Nationalisierungsprozesse im geteilten Oberschlesien. (1922–1939). Wien, 2010. 306 p. DOI: 10.7788/boehlau.9783412213619.
Miller A. “National Indifference” as a Political Strategy? // Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eura-sian History. 2019. No. 20 (1). P. 63–72. DOI: 10.1353/kri.2019.0003. EDN: ZJQMCA.
National Indifference and the History of Nationalism in Modern Europe. London: Routledge, 2019. 276 p.
Osterhammel J. Die Verwandlung der Welt: Eine Geschichte des 19. Jahrhunderts. Munich: C.H. Beck, 2009. 1568 S. DOI: 10.17104/9783406615016.
Smalianchuk A. Belaruski natsyianal´ny rukh i kraevaia ideia // Białoruskie Zeszyty Historyczne. 2000. No. 14. S. 105–114.
The Matica and Beyond. Cultural Associations and Nationalism in Europe. Leiden, Boston: Brill, 2020. 376 p.
Vlossak E. Marianne or Germania? Nationalizing Women in Alsace, 1870–1946. Oxford: Oxford Uni-versity Press, 2010. 330 p. DOI: 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199561117.001.0001.
Zahra T. Imagined Noncommunities: National Indifference as a Concept of Analysis // Slavic Review. 2010. No. 1. P. 93–119. DOI: 10.1017/S0037677900016715.
Zahra T. Kidnapped Souls. National Indifference and the Battle for Children in the Bohemian Lands, 1900–1948. Cornell University Press, 2008. 304 p.
References
Berecz, Á. (2019). Review of National Indifference and the History of Nationalism in Modern Europe, by M. Van Ginderachter & J. Fox. Hungarian Historical Review, 8(3), 636–638.
Bjork, J. E. (2008). Neither German nor Pole: Catholicism and national indifference in a Central European borderland. University of Michigan Press.
Bolin, P., & Douglas, Ch. (2007). "National indifference" in the Baltic territories? A critical assessment. Journal of Baltic Studies, 48(1), 13–22.
Brüggemann, K., & Wezel, K. (2019). Nationally indifferent or ardent nationalists? On the options for being German in Russia’s Baltic provinces, 1905–17. Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History, 20(1), 39–62.
Carrol, A., & Zanoun, L. (2011). The view from the border: A comparative study of autonomism in Alsace and the Moselle, 1918–1929. European Review of History, 18(4), 465–486.
Chikalenko, E. (2004). Shchodennik [Diary] (Vol. 1: 1907–1917). Tempora.
Cusco, A. (2019). Russians, Romanians, or neither? Mobilization of ethnicity and "national indifference" in early 20th-century Bessarabia. Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History, 20(1), 7–38.
Dragomanov, M. P. (1991). Vibrane [Selected]. Libіd'.
Hupka, Ja. (1936). Z czasów wielkiej wojny: Pamiętnik nie kombatanta [From the Great War: A non-combatant's diary]. Niwiska.
Judson, P. (2023). Making minorities and majorities: National indifference and national self-determination in Habsburg Central Europe. In Sovereignty, nationalism, and the quest for homogeneity in interwar Europe (pp. 21–38). Bloomsbury Academic.
Judson, P. M. (2006). Guardians of the nation: Activists on the language frontiers of imperial Austria. Harvard University Press.
Jurkiewicz, Ja. (Ed.). (1999). Krajowość – tradycje zgody narodów w dobie nacjonalizmu: Materiały z międzynarodowej konferencji naukowej w Instytucie Historii UAM w Poznaniu (11–12 maja 1998).) [Nationality – traditions of harmony of nations in the era of nationalism: Materials from the international scientific conference at the Institute of History, Adam Mickiewicz University in Poznań (11–12 May 1998)]. Instytut Historii UAM.
King, J. (2002). Budweisers into Czechs and Germans: A local history of Bohemian politics, 1848–1948. Princeton University Press.
Kraevaia ideia, kanets XIX – pachatak XX stagoddzia: Antalogiia [The kraj idea, late 19th – early 20th centuries: Anthology]. (2014). Palitychnaia sfera.
Martinyuk, O. (2016). Rosіys'kiy natsіonalіzm yak sotsіal'no-polіtichniy fenomen u viborchomu protsesі Pravoberezhnoї Ukraїni (1906–1912) [Russian nationalism as a socio-political phenomenon in the electoral process of Right-Bank Ukraine (1906–1912)] [Doctoral dissertation].
Michalczyk, A. (2010). Heimat, Kirche und Nation: Deutsche und polnische Nationalisierungsprozesse im geteilten Oberschlesien (1922–1939). Böhlau.
Miller, A. (2019). "National indifference" as a political strategy? Kritika: Explorations in Russian and Eurasian History, 20(1), 63–72.
Miller, A. I. (2024). Ukrainskiy vopros i politika identichnosti [The Ukrainian question and identity politics]. INION RAN.
National indifference and the history of nationalism in modern Europe. (2019). Routledge.
Osterhammel, J. (2009). Die Verwandlung der Welt: Eine Geschichte des 19. Jahrhunderts. C. H. Beck.
Osterhammel, J. (2024). Preobrazhenie mira [The transformation of the world] (Vols. 1–3). Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie.
Skoropads'kii, P. (1995). Spogadi: Kіnets' 1917 – gruden' 1918 [Memoirs: Late 1917 – December 1918]. Іnstitut ukraїns'koї arkheografії ta dzhereloznavstva іm. M.S. Grushevs'kogo NAN Ukrainy.
Slavyanskiye matitsy: XIX vek. [Slavic matitsa: 19th century]. (1996). (Vols. 1–2). Institut slavyanovedeniya i balkanistiki RAN.
Smalianchuk, A. (2000). Belaruski natsyianal´ny rukh i kraevaia ideia [Belarusian national movement and the kraj idea]. Białoruskie Zeszyty Historyczne, 14, 105–114.
The Matica and beyond: Cultural associations and nationalism in Europe. (2020). Brill.
Vlossak, E. (2010). Marianne or Germania? Nationalizing women in Alsace, 1870–1946. Oxford University Press.
Zahra, T. (2008). Kidnapped souls: National indifference and the battle for children in the Bohemian lands, 1900–1948. Cornell University Press.
Zahra, T. (2010). Imagined noncommunities: National indifference as a concept of analysis. Slavic Review, 69(1), 93–119.
